Question COVID-19
- marie7342231
-
Topic Author
Silver lining: Canon authors should have lots of time to write now. Am I right?
- ShadowedSin
-
"I can only conclude that I'm paying off karma at a vastly accelerated rate."
-Commander Susan Ivanova, Earth Force, Babylon 5
- JG
-
- Kristin Darken
-
I 'should' as far as I know at the moment, be working in the meantime... setting up and doing tech rehearsals so that we can open when we can have an audience again. But I don't know how things are going to play out. Losing weeks of performances is going to be rough on our already strained budget. And my personal budget is still in rough shape from spending a 2/3 of a month homeless and then getting a much higher priced apartment and deposit and outfitting the place.
On the bright side, I've seen that they have some evidence that this virus is temperature sensitive (doesn't like heat) and its ideal is between 45-50 degrees and 50-60% humidity. Our weather here should very quickly make Sacramento a much less friendly place for it by the time we start into April. Which is good... because I'm fairly sure my Gulf War affected respiratory system puts me on a higher risk group for this thing than I'd like to be.
Fate guard you and grant you a Light to brighten your Way.
- Wavehead
-
- JG
-
Conceiving children under the aurora borealis is considered auspicious, or so I have been told.
- null0trooper
-
Wavehead wrote: Well now that you mention it I had in early December what I thought was some odd type of flu but kept getting feeling very hot and sweaty for like five minutes followed by couldn't get warm enough for thirty minutes or so and a dry cough. I have never had a cold or flu like that before! Makes me wonder if right now is like a second wave or maybe a mutation of what was probably a new virus in December?
It's extremely unlikely that an existing orthomyxovirus would magically mutate into a coronavirus.
As it is, there are a lot of pathogens (some of them fungi or bacteria instead of viruses) that can cause fever and a dry cough for a period of time.
Forum-posted ideas are freely adoptable.
WhatIF Stories: Buy the Book
Discussion Thread
- Bek D Corbin
-
Covid-19; sounds like an alien or robot baddy from a 1960s SatAM cartoon.
On the upside, with the signal exception of the Chinese Central Government, I am pleasantly surprised by the sensible, responsible, mature reaction by most of the major players. Most of the moves that I've seen have been intelligent, timely and quite reasonable. People, DISNEY, a company known for their pious worship of the Bottom Line, has shut down their two major theme parks! AND, they're paying their workers for their sites their normal wages. Disney, go figure.
And people are singing bits from operas on their balconies in Italy. There may be more to this Human Race than it seems at times.
Still, you gotta wonder- what the HELL is the Chinese Government stonewalling? WHY are they stonewalling?
- Kristin Darken
-
Fate guard you and grant you a Light to brighten your Way.
- Sir Lee
-
Meanwhile, down here in Brazil we have a clown president who does not seem to be taking the issue as seriously as he should. Fortunately the Health Minister is one of the few competent people in his administration...
On a personal level, I'm postponing visiting my parents to avoid the risk of unwittingly carrying the virus to them (I live in São Paulo, they live in a rural area; I'm probably a thousand times more likely than them to get it, but due to their age, the risks of the disease are much worse for them).
Professionally... most of my work is done via remote access nowadays, so I don't meet that many people on a daily basis. But one of my customers asked me to set up a way for his workers to be able to work from their homes, in case we enter a China/Italy quarantine situation.
- JG
-
Kristin Darken wrote: I think they're just pissed because of all the shade being thrown their way because it started there. You know, all the paranoia conspiracy types who are saying the Chinese Government released it from a lab. You know... just like Iran is saying about the US. Mostly backlash from the trade wars, more than likely. At least they're to the point where they have the energy to accuse the US of something. I'd be more worried if they just had no energy to be upset at us anymore
it's not as paranoid when their Level 4 Disease research center is literally 300m from the meat market they said it started at. And this virus shows too many superbug traits for me to be fully convinced it's natural.
That's completely ignoring the response they sent to wuhan right before they started clamping down on information.
It's not a paranoid conspiracy. it's PLAUSIBLE.
I personally think someone fucked up by the numbers and China is really wantiong to not have that officially tacked onto the litany of failures in their handling of the situation
- Astrodragon
-
marie7342231 wrote: How is everyone holding up?
Silver lining: Canon authors should have lots of time to write now. Am I right?
No, we're spending all our time trying to buy toliet paper!

I love watching their innocent little faces smiling happily as they trip gaily down the garden path, before finding the pit with the rusty spikes.
- Mister D
-
JG wrote:
Conceiving children under the aurora borealis is considered auspicious, or so I have been told.
Trying it out is fun too.

Living in London, where on Friday a tube-train driver was diagnosed after his symptoms started to show.
Means that he was infectious for the weeks before, so most tube staff have good odds on having it.
"The future is already here. It's just unevenly distributed."

Measure Twice
- Mister D
-
Kristin Darken wrote: I think they're just pissed because of all the shade being thrown their way because it started there. You know, all the paranoia conspiracy types who are saying the Chinese Government released it from a lab. You know... just like Iran is saying about the US. Mostly backlash from the trade wars, more than likely. At least they're to the point where they have the energy to accuse the US of something. I'd be more worried if they just had no energy to be upset at us anymore
There's two strands of conversation here:
- There's the local situation in China, where each regional government is partially incentivised to not be the source of bad news, so sometimes the "nail that sticks out" gets hammered, even when they are talking about something vital.
- And there's the fact that China is only just industrialising. They're still at the cross-over between the "Cities as reservoirs of infection" stage, and the "access to modern transport systems" stage.
It's not just China, and it IS going to happen again.
Just make sure that your area has the infrastructure to deal with this in future.
Measure Twice
- Mister D
-
JG wrote:
Kristin Darken wrote: I think they're just pissed because of all the shade being thrown their way because it started there. You know, all the paranoia conspiracy types who are saying the Chinese Government released it from a lab. You know... just like Iran is saying about the US. Mostly backlash from the trade wars, more than likely. At least they're to the point where they have the energy to accuse the US of something. I'd be more worried if they just had no energy to be upset at us anymore
it's not as paranoid when their Level 4 Disease research center is literally 300m from the meat market they said it started at. And this virus shows too many superbug traits for me to be fully convinced it's natural.
That's completely ignoring the response they sent to wuhan right before they started clamping down on information.
It's not a paranoid conspiracy. it's PLAUSIBLE.
I personally think someone fucked up by the numbers and China is really wanting to not have that officially tacked onto the litany of failures in their handling of the situation
One of the strengths and one of the weaknesses of bureaucracies is that the task has to be done, no matter whether Albert Einstein or Homer Simpson is employed to do it.
The procedure for the tasks will have to be designed for both.
Add in the Peter Principle, where people get promoted to the point where they are incompetent, as they don't have the skill-set required.
This guarantees that someone somewhere will screw up.
Unless the system is designed to fail gracefully, then you'll get disasters.
Measure Twice
- Rose Bunny
-
Toilet Paper, Hand Sanitizer, Surgical Masks, and Bleach are selling out at all the stores near me. I went in to the grocery store today, and saw someone had emptied out the entire supply of canned tuna into a cart to purchase. No tuna sammiches for me.

High-Priestess of the Order of Spirit-Chan
- ShadowedSin
-
"I can only conclude that I'm paying off karma at a vastly accelerated rate."
-Commander Susan Ivanova, Earth Force, Babylon 5
- JG
-
It's not because the disaster itself is likely to cause you to starve.
it's because of idiots panic-buying everything in sight primarily. The ignorant, panicked reaction people are having is doing the real damage.
- mhalpern
-
Rose Bunny wrote: "A person is smart. People are dumb, panicky dangerous animals and you know it." - Agent K.
Toilet Paper, Hand Sanitizer, Surgical Masks, and Bleach are selling out at all the stores near me. I went in to the grocery store today, and saw someone had emptied out the entire supply of canned tuna into a cart to purchase. No tuna sammiches for me.
Its like no one has heard of bulk buying TP and normally only buys enough to last a couple weeks, not 1-2 months....
Any Bad Ideas I have and microscene OC character stories are freely adoptable.
- null0trooper
-
mhalpern wrote: Its like no one has heard of bulk buying TP and normally only buys enough to last a couple weeks, not 1-2 months....
Usually though, the thought process is "Do I want to make a trip into town just for that, or go ahead and get the 9- or 12- pack?"
Forum-posted ideas are freely adoptable.
WhatIF Stories: Buy the Book
Discussion Thread
- Kettlekorn
-
- Kristin Darken
-
Fate guard you and grant you a Light to brighten your Way.
- Bek D Corbin
-
The real problem is that while it IS the most logical way to minimize the spread of the virus, I can't help but feel that there are those already abusing the situation, and more will climb on that bandwagon. I have a bad feeling, and it has nothing to do with a microscopic bug
- Kristin Darken
-
Personally... as of Tuesday evening, our board and Exec Producer decided to close the theatre for the rest of the season... so we did some basic load out work to allow the summer theatre company to load into the space at the end of May when we would normally end... but basically, shut down two and a half months early for the season and laying everyone off. This year is determined not to allow me to have any savings...
Fate guard you and grant you a Light to brighten your Way.
- Erianaiel
-
I live in a country where the government tries to find a balance between "can't disrupt the economy" and "Oh dear Lord, the world is coming to an end".
People are strongly encouraged to work from home but, not yet, required to do so. Of course I already did much of my work from home so this does not change much for me.
Most shops are still open, though mostly at reduced hours, and contact between employees and customers is limited as much as feasible. Schools as well as restaurants, bars, cinemas and other businesses that can not avoid close contact or large groups are required to close so there is not much to do other than watching television and trying to get my daughter to not treat this as an unexpected vacation

Our health minister said, correctly in my opinion, that a full lockdown is not going to be all that useful. It will most likely prevent more cases from occuring but the moment you end the quarantaine the disease is likely to return within weeks. Unless we somehow manage to lock down the entire world for a month. And as long as we have clowns like Bolsanaro and incompetents like he who shall not be named it is impossible to erradicate this disease through quarantaine.
It seems to make more sense to have procedures in place that people can adhere to to minimise the spread of the disease. So far (granted it has only been three days) it appears to be working. The number of cases keeps rising but not the exponential growth we had initially.
For myself, like everybody else I can only try to weather this storm to the best of my ability and hope that common sense measures are sufficient. And to remember that the disease is most dangerous for elderly male smokers.
- Kristin Darken
-
But yes... while its not something people are talking much about... until vaccines and/or cures are developed and approved, we can expect most of the population to get this thing. Some few will be immune, others will be resistant enough to not see anything worse than a light cough or a fever... but its going to be just like the flu, something that comes around every once in a while and we just have to struggle through it.
On the bright side, there are a couple labs and hospitals claiming they have a cure and some vaccines have been developed... but that's a year to eighteen months off for them to be tested and approved for 'official' use.
Fate guard you and grant you a Light to brighten your Way.
- Sir Lee
-
1. China reported zero new cases, which suggests that shelter-in-place does work to break the chain of transmission. Most places lack the totalitarian power to do it to the extent the Chinese did, but it should still flatten the curve enough so the medical infrastructure can deal with it.
2. In the middle of the horror that is the Italian situation, which already has more dead than China (at least officially...), a small town managed to get totally rid of coronavirus by doing the South Korean script: checking everybody who might be contaminated.
3. Some drugs, including chloroquine and derivatives (malaria drugs), have been reported as being helpful in the treatment of the sick.
Down here in Brazil, we are... well, not good, and not terrible either. São Paulo, where I live, is the epicenter. Federal government is not being very helpful, but city and state governments have stepped in and decreed "shelter in place"-style policies. Schools, convention centers etc. have been closing since the beginning of the week. Starting tomorrow (Friday) and for the next two weeks, only essential stores are going to be open -- essentially, only commerce that deals with food or medicines. Lots of companies are moving to telecommuting as much as possible. The city is really quiet -- sorta like between Christmas and New Year's, when lots of companies close for the holidays and lots of people leave town for the holidays. Not desert, but traffic flowing really well. And the general stores shutdown didn't even begin yet.
That's São Paulo, though. Richest state in the country, with reasonably functional infrastructure -- not the best (Paraná has better health services), but OK. Rio is also quite big, but has been economically decadent for decades, with a very large, very impoverished part of the population. They had already had two deaths, and public & health services are quite worse there. And the politicians are the worst, both corruption-wise and competence-wise. I won't be surprised if the situation there gets very bad very quick.
- peter
-
Sir Lee wrote: 3. Some drugs, including chloroquine and derivatives (malaria drugs), have been reported as being helpful in the treatment of the sick.
.
Watts Up With That, had a page top blog for two weeks about Chloroquine, started right after the news came out from, China, Korea, and Australia, and President Trump mentioned it a week later, and the Chief Medical Officer? almost instantly said not so fast. We don't have any long term studies of how it works on this disease or how dangerous it might be.
My reaction was it's been in use for eighty years, is cheap as dirt, and can be produced in mass quantities quickly. Bayer has already promised three million free doses ready to go when they get the word.
And in those countries where it is widely used for Malaria control, there is a low incidence of the disease. Its side effects are minor for short time usage and well known. What is the problem with preventative measures?
I'm not one of those tin foil hat people, but I'm really hoping the fact that President Trump talked it up does not cause many to dismiss it out of hand.
- Mister D
-
A sobering perspective on how protocols can operate and fail, and the problems yet to come.
"It's like Ebola, but for old people,"
Measure Twice
- null0trooper
-
Mister D wrote: "It's like Ebola, but for old people,"
In New York, the demographics skew lower, probably because the mass transit systems that so many rely on (as in Italy) aren't all that safe for seniors. Ships, subways, airplanes, busses are all metal boxes lined with surfaces that don't harm coronaviruses and block out UV from sunlight.
One can argue that the Japanese also rely on trains, etc. But there, it's considered normal to wear a mask to avoid spreading whatever one might have to others.
Spread in Florida has been greatest in high-density population centers, but nowhere near as rapidly as New York or LA - taking 2 to 3 times as long to reach 600 patient. Then again, no feasible subways, limited rail corridors, a/c isnearly mandatory, and an 18 mile trip can take 3-4 hours by Metrobus.
Forum-posted ideas are freely adoptable.
WhatIF Stories: Buy the Book
Discussion Thread
- Sir Lee
-
The danger of putting one's hopes on an unproven* medication is that it distracts from other possible avenues of treatment.
*Unproven for Covid-19, that is. Chloroquine has a proven track record against malaria, but it also has toxicity problems. Derivatives are less toxic, though, but they have to be checked too. Every drug has risks, some less than others, and the decision to use them has to be based on understanding its risks and benefits.
- Kristin Darken
-
The 'reason' that this is working seems to be that this malaria treatment really fires up the immune system... and while its not specifically targeted at this virus, having the immune system acting that aggressively means its able to ramp up against Covid-19 quickly once it identifies it in your system. This is likely the same reason that drugs for fighting HIV are showing some effectiveness... again, its about ramping up the default state of your immune system so that when it does encounter the Covid-19 in your system, it can quickly respond instead of starting from 'factory shut down'. Not unlike a Naval vessel going to General Quarters or a military base going on Alert. It's not quite the same as knowing you have a missile inbound and taking the exact actions needed to stop it... but having enough time to take those actions is a lot easier from General Quarters than if you are in your bunk when that missile launches.
Fate guard you and grant you a Light to brighten your Way.
- Ametros
-
It's concerning though, looking out and seeing the ways things are elsewhere and how they're proceeding. I wish you all good fortune in the months to come.
Seriously, thank you for your time and effort. It is appreciated.
- Mister D
-
Necessary, but it should have been done much earlier.

Measure Twice
- Cryptic
-
I forget what number rule it is on the Evil Overlord list it is, but I'm pretty sure there is something bout listen to your advisors. The guy in the White House seems to be ignoring his advisors and trying to insist things are going to work on the time line he thinks should happen.
And people are calling him out on it, and while the governors and mayors haven't used the word Idiot, at least to me, it was implied.
I am a caffeine heathen; I prefer the waters of the mountain over the juice of the bean. Keep the Dews coming and no one will be hurt.
- Mister D
-
https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/23/opinion/coronavirus-young-people.html

Measure Twice
- Sir Lee
-
What does happen is that younger, healthier, stronger people catch the disease but in many (not all) cases are able to weather it until their immune system ramps up the production of antibodies against the virus. Meaning that they think "it's just a regular flu" or even "it's just a cold." Thing is, they can still infect other people, even if they never get sick enough to need to go to an hospital, and might not be recognized (and counted) as a COVID-19 case.
- JG
-
If someone tells you that it won't significantly affect young people, smack them, with words or a backhand if that happens to be legal. Young people aren't likely to die, HOWEVER, as an asthmatic I can tell you from experience. Permanent lung damage will make you wish it had.
- null0trooper
-
JG wrote: young people survive it more consistently. No one EVER said it doesn't tear the shit out of young people. The young respond to ventilators more consistently and readily than people over 50.
I'm sure it wouldn't take much searching to find one or more "journalists" claiming that SARS-CoV-2 is harmless to young people.
They should be taken just as seriously as the reports that Pres. Trump personally made that couple in Arizona swallow chloroquine phosphate meant for fish, or the writer I ran across yesterday claiming that chloroquine is worthless because it wasn't shown more effective than placebo to prevent infection with the virus.
Dosage and exposure make the medicine or the poison.
Forum-posted ideas are freely adoptable.
WhatIF Stories: Buy the Book
Discussion Thread
- JG
-
The couple who died drank FISH TANK cleaner that was Chloroquine Phosphate, the non-medical formulation. and a teaspoon if Chloroquine Phosphate is a sufficient dose to clean 125 GALLONS of fish tank water. And the warning on the back spells out "DO not Drink"
That whoile news story was a darwin award, not malfeasance in pushing malaria drugs.
- Rose Bunny
-
High-Priestess of the Order of Spirit-Chan
- Bek D Corbin
-
Rose Bunny wrote: What do you expect from people that are dumb enough to take a challenge to lick a toilet?
Natural Selection Test
- Sir Lee
-
Hilariously, Ann Coulter (yes, THAT Ann Coulter) made the claim on Twitter that coronavirus is "less dangerous than flu for people under 60"... while attaching a chart that showed the exact OPPOSITE.
- JG
-
- Cryptic
-
Why are you on tv back slapping and having your people kiss your ass and tell you how good a job you've done when this crisis is not over yet?
Sincerely, Turned Off
I am a caffeine heathen; I prefer the waters of the mountain over the juice of the bean. Keep the Dews coming and no one will be hurt.
- JG
-
It's that simple.
it also helps that HydroxyChloroquine is showing efficacy in killing this shitty virus.
- annachie
-
JG wrote: It's a morale trick. it's more effective than one might think. If morale tanks, everything tanks and it becomes that much harder to recover.
It's that simple.
it also helps that HydroxyChloroquine is showing efficacy in killing this shitty virus.
Except it's not.
and it's not.
Showing a disregard for basic precautions against covid-19 encourages others to disregard basic procedures. It is poor form. As is refusing to let the actual expert at a presser answer questions directed to said expert.
Added to the whole spreading incorrect information encourages people to distrust the US Federal government, though by this stage only idiots trust the US Federal Government.
Finally, the "We'll open everything by Easter" does wonders for morale when things don't open by Easter. Which would at least be better than the morale hit if things do open by Easter and there's a huge spike in the fatalities two weeks later. Which there would be.
HydroxyC is not showing consistent results. So far it MAY have helped people who were basically non-symptomatic. Where they were symptomatic it did diddly squat.
Granted all those studies were on small numbers. More of a spot check than a study.
Simply, results have not been repeatable.
In fact there's every chance that the regular flu shot will be just as effective. After all, it will also get the immune system working. Can't wait for result on that, but that will be months away.
However, people are now apparently panic buying Malaria meds, much to the harm of those who actually need it.
I'm paying attention to this shit. Last November my 15 yr old daughter was diagnosed with cancer. You learn how serious things are damn quick when you try and enter a pediatric cancer ward.
- JG
-
"I hope to open by easter" is not a statement of commitment.
Hydroxy chloroquine is being reported effective by doctors in both new york, LA and in multiple countries, so saying it doesn't work is dishonest. Saying it might just be treating symptoms is something to find out. there's too many unknowns. At least one doctor is reporting near-universal positive results when combining the drug with zinc and./or Z-pacs.
Z-Pacs alone are reported to have positive effects on patients with the virus.
But it's a morale trick that works because any leader who says "We're screwed" has failed at their job utterly. When the leader gives up, everything fails.
Finally, most of the people flouting the safety measures are under the age of thirty and convinced it won't affect them because early reporting says it only kills old people.
I've been paying attention, and I see trump as a Rorschach test. If you like him, you'll see everything he does in a positive, glowing spin. if you despise him you will see sinister dishonesty in every word.
If you divorce emotion and just realize that by 2024 he's out of the white house either way, just like every president since the constitution was amended, you see him as a Rorschach test. You see what he does right, you see what he fucks up, and you aren't blinded by adoration or hatred for him.
Avoid CNN, MSNBC and the New York Times coverage of the coronavirus epidemic. They've sensationalized and fear-mongered every step of the way. They ask the same questions over and over at the briefings, and every story they tell is framed. the other outlets aren't great, neither is fox or OAN, but the constant doomsayer attitude people have has gotten old, and frankly people are tired of it.
- MageOhki
-
Leadership in situations like this, is to inspire people, to convince them that it will be better.
FDR's famous quote is very much on point. "The only thing we have to fear, is fear itself." Leadership, again, in this type of situation is convincing people of that.
Putting aside partisan views, I have personally caught CNN in lies over the years, intentional lies, recently. Either by omission (bad enough), or by outright doing it. Being nice, the concept "If it bleeds, it leads..." is one reason why, but frankly? I have other reasons to believe that they are intentionally doing so. I have never believed in objective journalism (mostly because even from a fairly young age I figured out people are biased.) so I've always been careful to see as many sides of a story as is (plus, frankly, as I delved into history and politics, I realized how recent the concept was, and where it started.)
Side note: My wife is an MD, and everything she's read, found out and has seen says the drug combo works. Her suspicion (shared by several others she's currently working with) is because of the same reason why it's effective on malaria.
Disclaimer:
I did not vote for Trump in 2016. (Note the word, however, that does not mean I voted for anyone. I am very much an RAH type voter...) What I have seen and studied over the last three years, and some of his actions, well. Let's say this, I am very pleasantly surprised.
I hold degrees in History (Political, Asian and American as focus), and Political Science, (International Relations/Western Pacific region as focus)
- Kristin Darken
-
Yes, many people are saying it works. But many people could be saying that eating green jelly beans works... it would have the same level of scientific support backing it.
And there are enough very dangerous side effects that haphazardly taking this stuff is not a good idea. If its trying this or dying of Covid? I don't know... might be worth the risk... but remember, a LOT of people who die from this die because something else was wrong with them that the virus made worse. So taking a drug that can cause cardio-toxicity or other issues might not be wise. So using it as a preventative? Or if you're only showing light symptoms? Seems like a foolish risk.
Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying that doctors and nurses in hospitals that are trying this aren't seeing positive results. They may be. But you shouldn't give medical advice based on 'we tried it on six people and five of them got better'... well, yes... but how many of those six were going to get better anyway? And was that one who didn't going to die before you treated him with an untried medication or not? And WHY did they get better? Because if the malaria drugs are helping purely out of accelerating the activation of the immune system (coronavirii being something our immune system doesn't even recognize to start building antibodies) ... then there are probably MUCH safer ways to go about that.
As to the media and Trump and political side of this? Let's not go there. That's not a discussion that can be had without tempers flaring. We know this because every other time its started here, it went badly. So... just don't.
Fate guard you and grant you a Light to brighten your Way.
- JG
-
another reason why it seems to work is the same reason it's effective against malaria: Chloroquine opens the zinc channel in cells and zinc prevents cellular division (inhibiting viral load when it hijacks the cell processes). This comes with it's own downsides and too much zing is unequivocably bad.
But the risks are well known and the tolerance areas are extremely well-documented. Docs know who not to prescribe it to.
Are there risks? Yes. have there been controls? No.
But you don't have to have a control group to see a consistent pattern of results. the key I find is that docs started drop-kicking the drug two weeks ago, and they are still doing so.
Just dismissing the results reported as anecdotal and not valid is as irresponsible as blithely claiming that it's a cure-all for the disease. Bluntly I agree that it should remain available for right to try, so long as prescribed by a doctor. I'm nowhere remotely dumb enough to think that individuals should be able to get ahold of it without a doctor's script, severe symptoms and the desire to try.
I feel that self-medicating with chloroquine without understanding what it is, the dosing and how it works is no different than drinking fish tank cleaner.
Edit: I'm actually hoping the blood-plasma transfusions (AKA Convalescent Plasma therapy) turn up to be effective, because bluntly, that method is almost zero-risk and already shows promise
- null0trooper
-
JG wrote: Edit: I'm actually hoping the blood-plasma transfusions (AKA Convalescent Plasma therapy) turn up to be effective, because bluntly, that method is almost zero-risk and already shows promise
The method does show promise (it's been in use for a long time), but it's not risk-free.
"Risks commonly associated with FFP include: (1) transfusion related acute lung injury; (2) transfusion associated circulatory overload, and (3) allergic/anaphylactic reactions."
tl,dr: There are very good reasons for all the research into producing monoclonal antibodies.
Anecdote: A close relative used to require packed RBCs on a too-frequent basis. The units had to be washed, leukocyte-reduced, and irradiated and the blood bank required an extended lead time for the type and cross, specifically because the antibodies in plasma are not one-size-fits-all.
Forum-posted ideas are freely adoptable.
WhatIF Stories: Buy the Book
Discussion Thread
- JG
-
But treatments that have been refined since their inception in 1918-ish timeframe almost universally have the bugs worked out.
The only bugs you can't work out are unknown allergic reaction and human error at that point.
- Kristin Darken
-
JG wrote: But you don't have to have a control group to see a consistent pattern of results. the key I find is that docs started drop-kicking the drug two weeks ago, and they are still doing so..
To be fair, doctors are looking at overfull morgues and PTSD that is going to make some military service related versions look like campfire ghost stories... using anything with the slimmest hope has to look pretty good right now. Of course they're trying it. And confirmation bias could easily convince them its working.
Again... I'm not averse to it being tried / used given no other option. Same thing with any other method in trials. What I am against is it being presented as a cure, a prevention, or even something that will control or reduce the impact of the virus until we are certain that it is. Because that reduction or relaxation in mindset of this as a pandemic that could sweep across the country killing millions instead of just the thousands we've seen so far if we take it lightly? If people say, oh there's a cure so its ok if we start hanging out with friends... oh, don't worry, its not large gatherings. And hey, employers want people back to work, and there's so many unemployed right now... if you don't return, they can easily find someone else.
Fate guard you and grant you a Light to brighten your Way.
- annachie
-
MageOhki wrote: I have several points here to add, annachie
Leadership in situations like this, is to inspire people, to convince them that it will be better.
Except that to say things that are clearly wrong, or not possible, severely negative, or purely self aggrandizing is the exact opposite of inspiring them.
That is what Trump has done
Putting aside partisan views, I have personally caught CNN in lies over the years,
Yet Fox are the ones who argued, in court, that the FCC rules about honesty in news reporting were in fact not rules but guidelines.
Very few news organizations actually lie. They may spin things like a top, but few outright lie.
Though Fox* do. The French study, that Fox touted as a 100% cure rate, well it kind of discarded the results from four patients who didn't finish the study. Through being dead or in the ICU. Or quitting because of the side effects. Four might not be a lot to some people, but it was 10% of the patients. Not that it was in anyway actually scientific in the first place.
But hey, what would that little lie matter, except that President Trump saw it and started touting it. I'm sure it has nothing to do with a Ken Fisher, a huge Trump supporter, being one of the majority shareholder in the company that invented it.
And for all the good HydroxyC could possibly do, you're better of getting the current flu shot. It will actually protect you from the normal flu's, and not take medicine away from people who actually need it.
The real worthwhile study, which is actually going on, is to look at people who take HydroxyC for other reasons and see if they get the bloody thing.
*Fox news aren't too bad. Fox opinion would rather lie than tell the truth about just about anything. Trouble is that Fox interweave the two so much it's hard to tell the difference.
- JG
-
The real worthwhile study, which is actually going on, is to look at people who take HydroxyC for other reasons and see if they get the bloody thing.
This will be telling. It will also tell us a lot about whether HydroxyC is killing the virus or suppressing the symptoms.
- Mister D
-
If you have Diabetes, then you're in the higher risk categories for co-morbidity anyway, but the interactions of the combination of HCQ and the Diabetes medication can be fatal.
(Yes, there's the political problems in the USA, but the issues with the politics of how HCQ is handled in the EU is as much of a mess as it is in the USA.)
Anything that we say right now is purely speculation, as there is not enough data to give a fully functional model of how this virus operates.
One place that is useful to follow, if you want a better idea of the background is the Coursera modules found here, https://www.coursera.org/learn/covid-19/home/welcome
It's an effective introduction to the science, and the course is still being written as more data comes in.
Measure Twice
- Mister D
-
This current situation is a spectacular example of the Goat Rodeo.
Different actors with different agenda's based upon incompatible maps of reality, giving rise to conflicting actions when they're all supposed to be working together.
An excellent write-up here, https://www.northatlanticbooks.com/blog/of-warlords-and-rodeos-why-nothing-works/
SCIM is a basic map that describes the most common ways of dying, and how the infrastructures you use to stop this from taking place.
http://resiliencemaps.org/
No, it's not complete, but the adaptability is it's main strength.
The solutions that work in a desert will be different from the solutions for temperate climates. Solutions that work well in mountains will be different from solutions that work well in coastal swampland.
You'll have to do the analysis yourself, so you can specify it towards the micro-climate where you happen to be.
But, it at least, gives a shared map that everyone can work from, so all actors in a situation are operating from the same initial starting point.
It will also help to make clear what the agenda's are for each actor in a given situation.

Reducing the fragility, and increasing the resilience, of your local situation is a practical step that almost everyone can take, without putting any extra strain on the existing supply chains.

Two podcasts from one of the authors of the SCIM doc's can be found here, https://anchor.fm/fringe-voices/episodes/Coronavirus-and-Pandemics-with-Vinay-Gupta-ebdlc0
and here, https://anchor.fm/fringe-voices/episodes/Pandemics-and-Coronavirus-Part-2-with-Vinay-Gupta-ebi8ic
Part 2 gives a better explanation of how things can work well, and how the SCIM maps can be put into practise in a time-critical situation.
Lots of chewiness in there.
This approach has helped me make sense of things, so i'm just passing the gift on...

Measure Twice
- Astrodragon
-
annachie wrote:
Very few news organizations actually lie. They may spin things like a top, but few outright lie.
Oh dear. Which universe have you been living in recently?
They lie constantly by omission.
They lie by commission, and when called on it bury a retraction on page 37 in teeny timy print.
I love watching their innocent little faces smiling happily as they trip gaily down the garden path, before finding the pit with the rusty spikes.
- JG
-
The current running hypothesis is Cali was exposed to COVID as early as November 17 and as late as December 1st, so if this is true, this is bad because it means the casualties happened in fu season and got chalked up to seasonal flu. If it's true, it's good because that Means california's already got a partial immunity.
here's hoping that California silently endured their peak already.
- null0trooper
-
annachie wrote: And for all the good HydroxyC could possibly do, you're better of getting the current flu shot. It will actually protect you from the normal flu's,
Not necessarily this year's flu shot, which missed the mark rather badly this year.
annachie wrote: and not take medicine away from people who actually need it.
Hydroxychloroquine is not being administered to influenza patients.
annachie wrote: The real worthwhile study, which is actually going on, is to look at people who take HydroxyC for other reasons and see if they get the bloody thing.
There is no medication in real life that can prevent infection in the absence of sufficient exposure.
Even the number of United States cases come out to 1/6 of 1% of the population. If the virus were evenly spread among the population (which it is not) and the population were evenly distributed (which is definitely not) members of these small populations would have to stay close to (for an unknown amount of time) enough to 750 each before you could begin to assume that they were exposed on any given day.
That's an easy number to reach at a music festival or concert (which are closed down now, and are rarely accessible to people with rheumatoid arthritis or systemic lupus erythematosus), in an underground subway (which are limited to certain cities), and of course cubicle farms in office buildings. Crowds in general and even crowded stores or long checkout lanes are among the first things that people with limited mobility learn to avoid like a plague.
In short, not a good choice to pin decisions on.
Forum-posted ideas are freely adoptable.
WhatIF Stories: Buy the Book
Discussion Thread
- Kristin Darken
-
Fate guard you and grant you a Light to brighten your Way.
- JG
-
then two weeks ago I was able to breathe fully afterward.
And I agree with you, if your nose is stopped up you ain't tasting and smelling didly. I only am suspicious because my home state is a major port of entry for china and the symptom lists match.
- Kristin Darken
-
Fate guard you and grant you a Light to brighten your Way.
- Astrodragon
-
I love watching their innocent little faces smiling happily as they trip gaily down the garden path, before finding the pit with the rusty spikes.
- Bek D Corbin
-
- JG
-
No real information public. Any answer is pure conjecture at this time
- null0trooper
-
JG wrote: we had a rough one that blew right past the flu vaccines. I caught it in early deember, it finally let go in january. 4 weeks of pure hell.
There were a couple of oopses with this year's vaccine, and the influenza didn't feel like being cooperative.
JG wrote: And I agree with you, if your nose is stopped up you ain't tasting and smelling didly.
Stopped up nose dulls the senses of smell and taste, but not all the way. How would I know? Chronic vasomotor rhinitis since Nixon was President.
Forum-posted ideas are freely adoptable.
WhatIF Stories: Buy the Book
Discussion Thread
- Mister D
-
Bek D Corbin wrote: What's this I read about being able to catch COVID TWICE?
In Japan, there were some people who were treated for Covid-19, and were released as being clear, were later re-admitted after testing positive for Covid-19.
There is more than one potential cause:
- They may have been admitted having had a normal flu, that presented the same symptoms as Covid-19, before the full testing regime was brought in;
- There is evidence that shows that more than one strain of Covid-19 exists;
- Recovery and subsequent immunity to one strain does not mean that a recovered patient is immune to the other strains;

- There is also the error rates that the tests have, both in false positives, and in false negatives.
However I just read this today, https://www.jenniferzengblog.com/home/2020/4/10/symptoms-free-cases-found-in-multiple-communities-in-wuhan-

Measure Twice
- JG
-
- Sir Lee
-
- null0trooper
-
No big deal, except that some of the heart damage that COVID-19 patients are experiencing is suspected to be related to the generation of microthrombi (really small blood clots) and wouldn't it be nice to have an anticoagulant on-hand?
Note: Licking the cladding off galvanized steel will NOT help anything. While zinc deficiency impairs the senses of smell and taste (kind of like a certain virus) and the immune system, and it's critical to hundreds of enzymes, in excess it can be toxic. ( patient.info/doctor/zinc-deficiency-exce...-supplementation-pro )
Another interesting thing to keep in mind when running across op-ed pieces claiming that now is the time to go vegan and save the planet from meat production: heparin is sourced from the byproducts of meat processing. Not because it's cheaper, but because we still haven't figured out how animal bodies make it.
Edit: So... yesterday, Smithfield had to shut down one of the largest pork processing facilities in the US, and there was already a production shortage for heparin sodium. Just another way it's not the virus that kills, but the reaction to it.
Forum-posted ideas are freely adoptable.
WhatIF Stories: Buy the Book
Discussion Thread
- Cryptic
-
Here in the US the political crap ads are flying fast and furiously, and I've developed a Pavlovian response to Trump on tv; I flip him off.
Side note I worry about the number of gambling addicts that will emerge from this. I counted three ads for on line gambling in under ten minutes the other day.
I am a caffeine heathen; I prefer the waters of the mountain over the juice of the bean. Keep the Dews coming and no one will be hurt.
- marie7342231
-
Topic Author
Cryptic wrote: Ah it was nice while it lasted...
Here in the US the political crap ads are flying fast and furiously, and I've developed a Pavlovian response to Trump on tv; I flip him off.
Side note I worry about the number of gambling addicts that will emerge from this. I counted three ads for on line gambling in under ten minutes the other day.
Indeed it seems like it will get worse before it gets better. 2nd wave will hit hard, especially among those who refuse to wear a mask.
Stay home and stay safe everyone
- Sir Lee
-
- Kristin Darken
-
I explain it in terms of human learning process...
There's an innate sort of 'inertia' to knowledge. When you're acquiring / learning, its fairly easy to add to what you already know and build connections with your existing knowledge. But once you settle on a 'fact', it takes effort to 'move' it again. This is a necessary part of learning... if it didn't exist, we'd never be confident of anything we know and any new piece of knowledge would unseat previous knowledge too easily. Instead, to 'replace' what we know; the new data has to have a higher level of 'trust' than the original.
We measure our level of trust in two ways that we acquire the new information:
1. We trust the data depending on the level of trust in our own senses, as we acquire it personally through them... by seeing, hearing, touching, interacting with, and so forth. The more senses and means of personal interaction and the more we trust those senses and what we experience; the higher level of trust we place on the data.
2. We trust in people, primarily authority figures, but we apply that level of trust to any information they give us. The more we trust the person, the more we trust the information they give us.
Everyone has some measure of each of these, but most people are dominant in one of the two. Thus we have people who will typically trust and learn from things they personally experience more so than just because someone told them... and we have people who will believe what they've been told even when it contradicts their personal experience.
These are purely a measure of the functioning of the brain and cognitive development. They exist, as a matter of study... and they explain the conflict between science and religion, between skeptics and believers, between liberal and conservative mindsets... and numerous societal conflicts. Some natural... some artificially generated for someone's benefit.
Fate guard you and grant you a Light to brighten your Way.
- marie7342231
-
Topic Author
- Cryptic
-
I am a caffeine heathen; I prefer the waters of the mountain over the juice of the bean. Keep the Dews coming and no one will be hurt.
- Sir Lee
-
Meanwhile, the state and local governments (who up to now have been handling the crisis with some semblance of sanity) decided to begin relaxing the quarantine despite concerns that's too early. And the largest media outlets set aside their business rivalry and are collaborating in figuring out the real COVID-19 numbers, since the Federal government is no longer supplying them.
Myself? I have been doing as much of my work remotely as it's possible, and changed my habits so I don't have to leave home more than once every three days or thereabouts (I no longer purchase fresh bread every day, for instance...)
- Kristin Darken
-
Fate guard you and grant you a Light to brighten your Way.