Anything is fair game... just don't complain when someone with more Whateley-verse savvy shoots your theory out of the sky.
Posting rules: Any registered member can create threads or post to existing ones.
Question Kayda 8 - The Best Days of our Lives
- DanZilla
-
Phoenix Spiritus wrote: Found it!
Straight from the Squirrel’s Mouth: Chapter 5
Someone asked, “How’re you gonna get there? I’m guessing not Delta Airlines.”
Psydoe didn’t quite smile. “You’re never going to believe this, but the MCO. Mrs. Carson pulled a bunch of us who can’t travel on regular airlines into a meeting last month, and she said as part of the MID thing with the MCO and the DPA, the MCO helps us out with plane travel on special jets and stuff.”
“Aren’t you worried the MCO’s gonna make you disappear?” someone asked.
Psydoe laughed. “Yeah, Mrs. Carson said if any of us had any trouble with any of the MCO people, she’d track ‘em down and take care of ‘em herself. And it’s not like the MCO can kidnap me and then claim they don’t know what happened. A Whateley person’s riding down on the shuttle with us, and making sure we’re all set. It ought to be pretty good. No in-flight meals or stuff, but still pretty good.”
And I'm pretty sure one of the other stories from the same time talked about The Outcasts going to Australia, but I haven't found that one yet.
Ahh... I'd forgotten that since it was only ever mentioned that one time as an option...
The outcasts talk about going to Australia in the Call the Thunder storyline (part 6)... that's where I lifted the description of the plane that was used...
- mhalpern
-
Any Bad Ideas I have and microscene OC character stories are freely adoptable.
- Phoenix Spiritus
-

- elrodw
-
Topic Author


Never give up, Never surrender! Captain Peter Quincy Taggert
- Domoviye
-
elrodw wrote: I write an adventure with Jade, Ayla, Kayda, Charge, and Headrush - where Jade and Kayda create a whole lot of mayhem, and all you guys can do is talk about how a MINOR character is going to get to Whateley?
![]()
That does seem to be a problem on many threads.
- mhalpern
-
elrodw wrote: I write an adventure with Jade, Ayla, Kayda, Charge, and Headrush - where Jade and Kayda create a whole lot of mayhem, and all you guys can do is talk about how a MINOR character is going to get to Whateley?
![]()
Logistics is the bread of theory crafting, new characters are often the butter...
Any Bad Ideas I have and microscene OC character stories are freely adoptable.
- Valentine
-
elrodw wrote: I write an adventure with Jade, Ayla, Kayda, Charge, and Headrush - where Jade and Kayda create a whole lot of mayhem, and all you guys can do is talk about how a MINOR character is going to get to Whateley?
![]()
We expect Mayhem and Chaos from Jade and Kayda.
Now if Jade hadn't done anything wacky, we'd be talking about her.
Don't Drick and Drive.
- elrodw
-
Topic Author
Valentine wrote:
elrodw wrote: I write an adventure with Jade, Ayla, Kayda, Charge, and Headrush - where Jade and Kayda create a whole lot of mayhem, and all you guys can do is talk about how a MINOR character is going to get to Whateley?
![]()
We expect Mayhem and Chaos from Jade and Kayda.
Now if Jade hadn't done anything wacky, we'd be talking about her.
But ... I left a BIG challenge to find all the little bits of pop culture I was channeling into this! And there are some obscure ones to make it a big challenge.
Never give up, Never surrender! Captain Peter Quincy Taggert
- Domoviye
-
- DanZilla
-
And that nice Mr. Delacroix... I think he just needed a rest.
- Valentine
-
elrodw wrote:
Valentine wrote:
elrodw wrote: I write an adventure with Jade, Ayla, Kayda, Charge, and Headrush - where Jade and Kayda create a whole lot of mayhem, and all you guys can do is talk about how a MINOR character is going to get to Whateley?
![]()
We expect Mayhem and Chaos from Jade and Kayda.
Now if Jade hadn't done anything wacky, we'd be talking about her.
But ... I left a BIG challenge to find all the little bits of pop culture I was channeling into this! And there are some obscure ones to make it a big challenge.
I asked about Ayla's moldy soda? There were others?

Don't Drick and Drive.
- Phoenix Spiritus
-
- Malady
-
Okay, something more major than Amelie... (Edit: Well, I guess if she wasn't so difficult to transport, we wouldn't have said anything??)...The French MCO is gonna get a bit less obviously bigoted or something?
Hmm... America's pretty isolated, compared to Europe... How much does the MCO of foreign, bordering countries impact a country's MCO's stance on mutants?
We've gotten through 11 days in 1 part... Is that a bit fast, or just me?
Where is everyone going again? We're only in ~2nd week of July, school starts up again in September...
Charge is staying in France, IIRC? So she's got that thread with her French friends and the French MCO...??
- DanZilla
-
Malady wrote: We've gotten through 11 days in 1 part... Is that a bit fast, or just me?
Where is everyone going again? We're only in ~2nd week of July, school starts up again in September...
Charge is staying in France, IIRC? So she's got that thread with her French friends and the French MCO...??
We're not trying to cover every second of every day... In fact, as we go forward we're making an attempt not to...
Sure there are stories that could be told... But we would like to reach the start of the second year at Whateley WITHIN this decade...
Besides... if we filled everything up where would the fan-fictions and micro-scenes go?
- elrodw
-
Topic Author
Malady wrote: We've gotten through 11 days in 1 part... Is that a bit fast, or just me?
Where is everyone going again? We're only in ~2nd week of July, school starts up again in September...
As Danzilla said, we're only hitting highlights. There will probably NOT be a Charge story for the summer, nor a Headrush tale. There will be either a late-summer vignette with Kayda, or it'll be folded into the 'back to school' tale where she and Danny head cross-country to Whateley. (Most likely the latter.)
Even for a mutant high-school kid, most of life is BORING

Never give up, Never surrender! Captain Peter Quincy Taggert
- Dpragan
-
Have to wonder now what Jade would look like in Dream-space: a 9-tailed fox-pup, or like a Jade version of a "Last Supper Painting" ala the Loose cannons Movie.(Which I can't find right now)
In the end reality is only consensual! It means that Al Gore is causing "Global Warming" by his rhetoric alone! Fortunately, there are enough Global Warming "Deniers" still about to keep him from boiling the planet.
=^+^=
- mittfh
-

Meanwhile, Addy's probably likely to spend the summer helping out with the winery and touching base with Collette again, so barring Lorraine doing something stupid, there's not going to be much of interest to report on from France. Similarly, Alicia's likely to have an uneventful remainder of summer, as will Nikki, Lainie and Cody. Possibly even Tansy, since Amelia may not request she do anything out of the ordinary in between studying (and it should be relaxing given the Three Little Pests will almost certainly be back with their families).
Ayla and Jade - now that's going to be an interesting story if anyone's sufficiently motivated and has the blessing of Diane (since IIRC Babs has been AWOL for years - so sadly we're unlikely to see any tales solely from Jade's PoV), although I wouldn't be surprised if the details of the very public return of Wondercute remain a Noodle Incident.
-oOo-
Anyway, onto the tale itself, and there's got to be backstory behind the sudden transition of the Mistress of Mayhem / Prankster Princess of Poe into a professional-looking PA stroke bodyguard - knowing Jade, there's more to the "reading glasses" than meets the eye (never mind she probably had Jann-sensei activated). Her ambitions for post-Whateley may be expanding beyond her initial thoughts of the ultimate babysitter / child care service (and even if she did set one up, her work experience with Ayla will teach her the practicalities and administration end of running a business). Heck, it's even possible that during her tour of the winery, some of the J-Team were engaging in their own covert tour, finding out things that could never be done overtly (e.g. eavesdropping on employee conversations / attitudes, to get a more holistic and accurate view of how the business actually works day-to-day).
Then onto the meeting with Jean-Michel and Lorraine - somehow I think their relationship might be a little more rocky in future, especially given later events... quickly followed by a reconciliation with Collete (this time as platonic friends), Amelie's revelation and Kayda giving Nicole an idea of how to disprove Addy's fears.
Unsurprisingly, Lorraine's rather peeved at seeing her rival and current flame (but for how much longer?!) together, enjoying themselves - and as I read that passage, I had Vivaldi's Summer running through my head - the first few movements are slow and gentle, but with occasional rumblings of the oncoming storm.
Oh, that's another thing Addy will be doing over the rest of the summer - getting to know Nicole and inviting her into her life, after pushing her away since she entered the family.
Then over to the nightclub, and the worst mistake of Delacroix's career: "She's too young to be a mutant."
Evidently some of the J-Team were already out and about (or were launched immediately after) Kayda noted they were being followed, given the reports a few minutes later of how many members of the BCMF were following them. Then out comes Kitty Compact, the J-Team unlocking the museum door from inside (inside the door itself, that is!) and disabling the alarm (or, perhaps more likely, Amelie's power temporarily disabled it, while the J-Team found the relevant sensor and found something with which to keep the circuit closed). I like the touch of the museum being sponsored by Ayla's estranged mum

Evidently Jade has Jann-Sensei activated in the museum, hence she can guide the other two around, possibly with other J-Team members doing recces. Then the hijinks start... there's likely to be some Home Alone references in there somewhere (Jade's bound to have watched it and made notes!) as well as Night at the Museum, Then later on, Kayda lets Tatanka out to play (is it worrying she's picking up stretegy tips from Jade?!) from a display of his European relatives, before eventually things calm down and the Heroes Glorieux de Bordeaux arrive, to find the three girls (plus J-Team member in the T-Rex) playing cards.
Oh, and as for the earlier question about Kayda and Jade, she (and her spirits) know there's a "connection" between Jade and Jinn - I can't remember if they've spotted a connection with the various non-humanoid incarnations of the J-Team. However, there's a world of difference between knowing Jade's doing something other than using devises and figuring out her real abilities (which, let's face it, are unique even by Whateleyverse standards). It is, however, possible that at some point in their remaining 3 years at Whateley, Kayda finds out something closer to the truth, either by discovery and analysis or being told by Jade herself. It's likely that if Jade and the J-Team were examined more closely by Kayda's spirits, they'd find yet another dimension to the complexity of Jade (her 'stuck'ness, her relationship to the J-Team, the J-Team creation process...) But as with Dpragan above, I'd be curious to see her default appearance and environment in Dreamspace. Given what we've seen so far (especially with Angel being able to touch her without incident), she'd definitely appear in female form and probably Jinn-in-human-form sized. Heck, there's probably a Lakota spirit or two which have similar personality characteristics to her (from the PoV of meeting and conversing with in Dreamspace, rather than anything else)...
As the right side of the brain controls the left side of the body, then only left-handers are in their right mind!
- Dpragan
-
Poor Jet would be Shemp. I wonder how she is doing anyway, with Sara MIA?
In the end reality is only consensual! It means that Al Gore is causing "Global Warming" by his rhetoric alone! Fortunately, there are enough Global Warming "Deniers" still about to keep him from boiling the planet.
=^+^=
- DanZilla
-
- Arcanist Lupus
-
"Shared pain is lessened; shared joy, increased — thus do we refute entropy." - Spider Robinson
- Sir Lee
-
Another thing to remember is that Jade does not like charity. She feels her services have been ridiculously overpaid -- in advance -- by Ayla placing that bet in her name. So she is making damn sure that Ayla will receive his money's worth. If this means playing "ridiculously efficient PA" for a few days, that's what she's going to do.
- elrodw
-
Topic Author
And ... we have a winner!Sir Lee wrote: I think that the explanation for Jade's apparent switch to professionalism is simple: she's playing a role. She enjoys role-playing -- she has played Ghost, Robot Cabbit, Shoulder Angels, Waitress and probably others I can't recall right now. And she is supposed to have played "bodyguard/PA" for Ayla before, allegedly during Spring Break in New York. (a story Diane never released but she hinted about).
Another thing to remember is that Jade does not like charity. She feels her services have been ridiculously overpaid -- in advance -- by Ayla placing that bet in her name. So she is making damn sure that Ayla will receive his money's worth. If this means playing "ridiculously efficient PA" for a few days, that's what she's going to do.
Time for a confession - I read the bits Diane had written and the outline of the spring break story, so I knew how she'd presented Jade, which was much the same as I did - wanting to do a hyper-good job because she was being paid for it. So it wasn't my original idea, but it (would have) worked so well in the spring break story that I had to use it. The impish smiles she threw in to confuse Kayda - that was my addition

Never give up, Never surrender! Captain Peter Quincy Taggert
- Domoviye
-
- amratner
-
- Phoenix Spiritus
-
Domoviye wrote: Alright people seem to be missing one of the older pop references so here it is.
Warning: Spoiler! [ Click to expand ] [ Click to hide ]
Yay!
And I think I saw a Harry Potter callout, but that could just have been where I saw it first and it was actually referencing something earlier like Starman.
- Arcanist Lupus
-
That said, I think that the museum incident proves that Jade had a lot of creativity bursting at the seams.
Watching people underestimate the vampire princess will never get old.
"Shared pain is lessened; shared joy, increased — thus do we refute entropy." - Spider Robinson
- amratner
-
Since Eldrich is teaching them, I would expect all of team TAO (or whatever they decide to name themselves" to get guns.
- amratner
-
- Malady
-
amratner wrote: Since Eldrich is teaching them, I would expect all of team TAO (or whatever they decide to name themselves" to get guns.
crystalhall.wikia.com/wiki/Handmaid's_Own
- elrodw
-
Topic Author
Thank you for your snotty-ass comments by which critique you really, really don't do a hell of a lot for authors who write this FOR FREAKIN' FREE! A PM? Sure, tht would have worked, and a LOT of people in the past have done so, which I take as constructive criticism, but apparently you wanted to demean a non-French-speaking author in public.
Thanks, asshole.

Never give up, Never surrender! Captain Peter Quincy Taggert
- jmhyp
-
Jade being Jade. Without her inner monologue, it's missing a little something. But since she never felt she was in danger, her being playful worked well.
Kayda isn't usually this observant. I suppose that's because she's usually frantically dodging death threats so we're only now getting to see this side of her.
One thing was off and it was just in passing. Ayla voluntarily wearing makeup? Since when? Is that Addy's influence?
- elrodw
-
Topic Author
jmhyp wrote: Loved the beginnings of a Addy accepting Nicole in her home. That reveal of the pictures was forceful, emotional, and just damn good.
Thanks. It was a little hard to write to get the feel to it being both plausible and highly emotional.
Jade being Jade. Without her inner monologue, it's missing a little something. But since she never felt she was in danger, her being playful worked well.
Jade is hard to write, period. How much did she think she was in danger? Hard to say since it's a Kayda first-person POV story, but probably more than Kayda noticed. I don't get a chance to rummage around in her brain. And who says she was being playful when she was shooting those "innocent little smiles" at Kayda ...
Kayda isn't usually this observant. I suppose that's because she's usually frantically dodging death threats so we're only now getting to see this side of her.
Yeah, that's a good way to put it.
One thing was off and it was just in passing. Ayla voluntarily wearing makeup? Since when? Is that Addy's influence?
During parts of the trip, Ayla has to look professional, ergo, like a serious female tycoon. Yeah, Addy would have helped, but it'd be something Ayla would do to keep up the proper image. Ayla knows expectations in the business world, and will work to not stray from those. If we had seen Ayla's spring break story, I think this would have seemed less an issue to the readers.
Never give up, Never surrender! Captain Peter Quincy Taggert
- Kristin Darken
-
mmHmm. It makes me wonder how these people survive reading regular published material, honestly. Where they can't just throw a quick post off on a comment page demanding that someone fix that blaring error. That ONE horrible, torturous error. That didn't prevent the moment from being understood. Because, you know... its killing them to know that there's an improper usage of a special case of possessive adjective somewhere on the internet.And in print media... there's no one to complain to!??!!elrodw wrote: Thanks, asshole.
At least this one made a nice post about the story before their OCD got the best of them.
Fate guard you and grant you a Light to brighten your Way.
- Astrodragon
-
Support your local comma...
I love watching their innocent little faces smiling happily as they trip gaily down the garden path, before finding the pit with the rusty spikes.
- Valentine
-
elrodw wrote:
jmhyp wrote: Jade being Jade. Without her inner monologue, it's missing a little something. But since she never felt she was in danger, her being playful worked well.
Jade is hard to write, period. How much did she think she was in danger? Hard to say since it's a Kayda first-person POV story, but probably more than Kayda noticed. I don't get a chance to rummage around in her brain. And who says she was being playful when she was shooting those "innocent little smiles" at Kayda ...
Danger for Jade is kind of relative. On a scale of 0-10, where 0 is Jade safe at
I think the only time Jade is really "safe," is when she is travelling by commercial aircraft.
Support your local Serif.
Don't Drick and Drive.
- Yolandria
-

Clearly El is supporting Adjective local 2314. =)
Mistress of the shelter for lost and redeemable Woobies!
- Valentine
-
One attempted lethal attack on them, and the HGB would have arrived to find a group of MCO corpses playing cards.
I wonder how long Kayda's "knockout juice" spell lasts, and if there is a small bottle of it and a porcupine quill in Jade's purse.
Don't Drick and Drive.
- elrodw
-
Topic Author
Never give up, Never surrender! Captain Peter Quincy Taggert
- Valentine
-
elrodw wrote: Okay, since no-one is guessing anymore, the quill and knockout juice were inspired by Yellowbeard, where the doctor was using the concoction to knock out the priests on El Nebuloso's island.
I have to admit I never saw Yellowbeard.
Don't Drick and Drive.
- elrodw
-
Topic Author
Valentine wrote:
elrodw wrote: Okay, since no-one is guessing anymore, the quill and knockout juice were inspired by Yellowbeard, where the doctor was using the concoction to knock out the priests on El Nebuloso's island.
I have to admit I never saw Yellowbeard. This may be why. John Cleese called this movie "One of the six worst films made in the history of the world."
Might be because Cleese's role was relatively minor, and they killed his character off before the main action happened. It's a good movie for Graham Chapman as Yellowbeard, and IIRC, it's Marty Feldman's last movie.
Never give up, Never surrender! Captain Peter Quincy Taggert
- DanZilla
-
Valentine wrote:
elrodw wrote: Okay, since no-one is guessing anymore, the quill and knockout juice were inspired by Yellowbeard, where the doctor was using the concoction to knock out the priests on El Nebuloso's island.
I have to admit I never saw Yellowbeard.
This may be why. [ Click to expand ] [ Click to hide ]John Cleese called this movie "One of the six worst films made in the history of the world."
Awww... I dunno... some of the most memorable quotes and scenes, from movies I watched when I was younger, came from that movie...
Harvey "Blind" Pew: It sounded as though there was a bit of a squabble.
Moon: Squabble? They're all dead!
Harvey "Blind" Pew: Oh! Must have been more of a tiff then.
- elrodw
-
Topic Author
Never give up, Never surrender! Captain Peter Quincy Taggert
- brudin
-
- Kettlekorn
-
Seeing Dreamspace!Jade might be fun for us. It might be less than good for Jade, however. Remember the Mirror of Erisid from the first Harry Potter book?mittfh wrote: But as with Dpragan above, I'd be curious to see her default appearance and environment in Dreamspace. Given what we've seen so far (especially with Angel being able to touch her without incident), she'd definitely appear in female form and probably Jinn-in-human-form sized. Heck, there's probably a Lakota spirit or two which have similar personality characteristics to her (from the PoV of meeting and conversing with in Dreamspace, rather than anything else)...
Well, it's not like she has to use authentic fossils to achieve the desired effect. We've already seen that she's crafty, and Whateley does have some pretty nifty fabrication facilities. Wouldn't be hard for her to just make her own dinosaur skeleton, probably with bonus features hidden inside the bones. Because Jade.Domoviye wrote: If Jade had somehow managed to keep the T-Rex bones, it would have been awesome at Whately. Maybe she can get some at Whately and keep them for when she needs a pet with big sharp teeth.
Also, the story never said which dinosaur it was. I'm guessing not a T-Rex though, since Jade does have a size limitation. If she hasn't expanded her range in the last several months, it would probably take at least five or six members of the J-Team working in concert to animate an adult T-Rex without finding ways to cheat (e.g. attach cables to use as tendons with the ends running into a central core that she could occupy, but then she might run into her strength limits, so she may have to also include powerful springs to counterbalance the weight of the skeleton...). A younger T-Rex might not occupy as many Jade shards though.
Deinonychus would be a lot easier to work with than T-Rex, and it would also be easier to store and transport while not in use. For those who don't know, Deinonychus is what the Jurassic Park "Velociraptor" was based on, rather than actual Velociraptors. They just borrowed the Velociraptor's name since it sounds cooler. (Real Velociraptors were the size of chickens, shaped slightly differently, and just the cutest little monsters you ever did see.) If she was feeling ambitious, she could also probably pull off a Utahraptor, which is bigger (perhaps the size of Razorback), but she'd probably have to cheat for the tail, or use an extra Jade.

Just last Thursday I was griping to myself about a harmlessly-missing comma in The Shadow Rising by Robert Jordan (fourth Wheel of Time book). For me, that sort of discovery is actually sort of encouraging. It reminds me that even the greats are human.Kristin Darken wrote: It makes me wonder how these people survive reading regular published material, honestly. Where they can't just throw a quick post off on a comment page demanding that someone fix that blaring error. That ONE horrible, torturous error. That didn't prevent the moment from being understood. Because, you know... its killing them to know that there's an improper usage of a special case of possessive adjective somewhere on the internet.And in print media... there's no one to complain to!??!!
But to answer your wondering, it's pretty easy to survive. The key is that we simply are not the kind of people you seem to think we are. I'm not sure exactly what your POV is, but it seems as though you think that it's innately rude to point out an error in somebody's work unsolicited without doing it in private and with extreme diplomacy, and therefor anybody who behaves in that rude manner must have some sort of flaw motivating them -- they're obsessed, or malicious, or egotistical. But that is only true of people who share your particular arbitrary set of manners.
To some people, offering blunt, unsolicited correction of errors is not rude. And it's not because they're insensitive, antisocial, or stupid. It's because they have a different version of manners, different cultural rules. For them and the people they're used to, pointing out and sometimes debating errors isn't just something they think is helpful. It is something that is actually the normal, desired, friendly behavior. This is common among programmers, for example.
If somebody has that simple, frank, open attitude toward talking about their own and others' errors, then it doesn't take any special need to prompt them to report on an error. It's just the right thing to do, no big deal. And if there is nobody in a position to fix it to report the error to, or it would be too inconvenient, then they simply shrug and move on because it was no big deal.
All this obviously causes confusion and sometimes pain among people for whom it is a big deal, when either party mistakenly thinks that what they think is obvious is actually obvious. Yay cultural dissonance. I for one try to apply When In Rome, since obviously it's your house and your rules. Other people perhaps don't realize just how badly their posts will be taken, despite the warnings. Frankly, it can be hard to anticipate just how sensitive you guys are about some things until seen in action. I know I was somewhat shocked and confused the first times I saw people set you guys off.
Sorry if this doesn't help. I've been trying to make it sensible and respectful for a good bit now, and the fusion ball is now firmly up in the sky, mocking me with its daylight as I weave between proofreading and dreamhaving, so I'm throwing in the towel and declaring the turd polished. It is well past time to sleep a little.
- elrodw
-
Topic Author
The reveal of the day:
The tiny figures are a joint homage to Asterix and Obelix, and the miniatures in Night at the Museum. The specific figures called out are:
the short one with winged helmet - Asterix.
the tall fat one in blue and white striped pants - Obelix.
the tall skinny one with very long beard - (not, it's NOT Galdalf!) Getafix the druid.
Never give up, Never surrender! Captain Peter Quincy Taggert
- Kristin Darken
-
A programmer who regularly waits until meetings with the Project Manager or the owner to point out the typos in someone else's work is not going to be treated with the same respect/gratitude as the one who drops by your cubicle and says "hey, you might double check that formula in the sort module... there's an extra Parenthesis in there that is probably skewing your exit conditions." One is helpful, the other is intentionally showing where they are better than you... possibly at the expense of pay/job.
Just as there is a difference between saying "You've got a uncommon condition error. If you have someone really good with inheritences, haven't them look at X and Y. If not, I can walk you through where I think you might be having trouble." vs "Don't you guys have an actual Java coder on the team? There's several places that you need to fix inheritance on or in this one rare condition you'll get an error code. You'll still get good data... but you'll have to see and shut off that error code every time." One is pointing out that its understandable that there's a glitch, because its a special case that not everyone might know about, so you need to put the right person on it. The other implies that you don't have anyone who knows as much as they do and you should listen to them on how to fix it.
That's what posting a typo note in public comments is like for an author. It's not so much a sensitivity on behalf of the author's thing as you think. It's a difference in how we perceive the the relationships. When you post a typo note in the comments... do you remove it once the typo is gone? Most don't. That means that every reader from now until 'the end of time' who reads that story is going to see that I made a typo. And yet, I may have fixed that typo within an hour of release. One reader see's someone being helpful and says "oh, me too... there was a problem with X" Listing problems with a story sets a tone, encouraging others to do the same. How many typo notes do you think it takes before such conversations overpower the acknowledgements/kudos and even begin to impact more general feedback?
And you're not wrong... it may seem like we push eggshell walking sometimes. But truthfully? If that's what it takes to ensure that no more authors walk away from the project feeling like they're unappreciated... then walking on eggshells it will be.
But honestly, its not unrealistic to ask for typo/easy fix notes happen via PM. MOST story sites ask that. Because if something IS fixed, the comment no longer applies. And the issue of taking more involved discussion to the forums is purely practical for me. Forums discussion can be policed by the community, to some degree, and the whole author pool can moderate as needed. But the comment system is built to only be administered from the admin-backend, ie by me. The more involved the conversations and so on in the comments, the more time I have to spend every day on just that.
Fate guard you and grant you a Light to brighten your Way.
- Kettlekorn
-
- Kristin Darken
-
We're really quite capable of taking feedback (some of the feedback we give each other is pretty hardcore), its not an oversensitivity thing. But there is a LOT more of it than most readers see (because most authors subscribe to their own story comments, so they continue to see new comments long past the point where most readers have finished reading and are no longer tracking comments for that story... and of course, I see them all daily) and it builds up. Unfortunately, the people who take it personally when we do comment or remind people about policy... are generally not the ones we're trying to reach.
Fate guard you and grant you a Light to brighten your Way.
- Dreamer
-
Ah, missed the miniatures from Night at the Museum part in that scene, should had have remembered a similar scene from the movie. Did note Asterix, Obelix, and Getafix in my comments, hard to forget a helmet like Asterix's once you've seen it and love the reference to him and his friends. I need to start watching out for more easter eggs like that in stories from now on, fun to figure them out and see the Whateley characters interact with such things from pop culture, etc.elrodw wrote: it's safe to assume that the dino skeleton was like a small (2m) allosaurus.
The reveal of the day:
The tiny figures are a joint homage to Asterix and Obelix, and the miniatures in Night at the Museum. The specific figures called out are:
the short one with winged helmet - Asterix.
the tall fat one in blue and white striped pants - Obelix.
the tall skinny one with very long beard - (not, it's NOT Galdalf!) Getafix the druid.
Thank You for story comments appreciated and help me know me they are being read and liked.

- elrodw
-
Topic Author
Dreamer wrote:
Ah, missed the miniatures from Night at the Museum part in that scene, should had have remembered a similar scene from the movie. Did note Asterix, Obelix, and Getafix in my comments, hard to forget a helmet like Asterix's once you've seen it and love the reference to him and his friends. I need to start watching out for more easter eggs like that in stories from now on, fun to figure them out and see the Whateley characters interact with such things from pop culture, etc.elrodw wrote: it's safe to assume that the dino skeleton was like a small (2m) allosaurus.
The reveal of the day:
The tiny figures are a joint homage to Asterix and Obelix, and the miniatures in Night at the Museum. The specific figures called out are:
the short one with winged helmet - Asterix.
the tall fat one in blue and white striped pants - Obelix.
the tall skinny one with very long beard - (not, it's NOT Galdalf!) Getafix the druid.
I forgot - the green soldiers from Toy Story were part of that multi-theme homage.
The attack of the plushies was inspired by the evil teddy bear in Toy Story 3 AND the swarming attacks in other Toy Story movies.
Never give up, Never surrender! Captain Peter Quincy Taggert
- Valentine
-
I really don't care for stories that are unwilling to use real places. The addition of minor things like Dunwich and Whateley's don't count, they still go to Boston, NYC, LA, etc. It's one of things that I don't like about DC Comics.
Don't Drick and Drive.
- elrodw
-
Topic Author
Valentine wrote: One thing I should have mentioned before. Thanks for using real places.
I really don't care for stories that are unwilling to use real places. The addition of minor things like Dunwich and Whateley's don't count, they still go to Boston, NYC, LA, etc. It's one of things that I don't like about DC Comics.
Glad you like that. I have a problem writing a place that doesn't feel or seem 'real'. It's more work, but using real places give me access to details to flesh out the setting. It's nice to know that people notice and appreciate the extra effort.
Never give up, Never surrender! Captain Peter Quincy Taggert
- Malady
-
elrodw wrote:
Valentine wrote: One thing I should have mentioned before. Thanks for using real places.
I really don't care for stories that are unwilling to use real places. The addition of minor things like Dunwich and Whateley's don't count, they still go to Boston, NYC, LA, etc. It's one of things that I don't like about DC Comics.
Glad you like that. I have a problem writing a place that doesn't feel or seem 'real'. It's more work, but using real places give me access to details to flesh out the setting. It's nice to know that people notice and appreciate the extra effort.
As a light comic reader? Or a reader of webcomics that aren't made to seem like the modern day, the use of real locales is invisible? But, now that I notice it, it's pretty nice! Same with the worldbuilding! It makes it seem more 'real'.
Edit: Oh, Valentine, you specified stories in general... I'm finding it hard to think of stories that are modern-day-ish, and are set on Earths, but use made-up places, and aren't set in a isolated area...
- Valentine
-
Malady wrote:
elrodw wrote:
Valentine wrote: One thing I should have mentioned before. Thanks for using real places.
I really don't care for stories that are unwilling to use real places. The addition of minor things like Dunwich and Whateley's don't count, they still go to Boston, NYC, LA, etc. It's one of things that I don't like about DC Comics.
Glad you like that. I have a problem writing a place that doesn't feel or seem 'real'. It's more work, but using real places give me access to details to flesh out the setting. It's nice to know that people notice and appreciate the extra effort.
As a light comic reader? Or a reader of webcomics that aren't made to seem like the modern day, the use of real locales is invisible? But, now that I notice it, it's pretty nice! Same with the worldbuilding! It makes it seem more 'real'.
Edit: Oh, Valentine, you specified stories in general... I'm finding it hard to think of stories that are modern-day-ish, and are set on Earths, but use made-up places, and aren't set in a isolated area...
Fanfic-er's rant? [ Click to expand ] [ Click to hide ]... if a real pain to make Alt Hist. for, with sufficiently large Points of Divergence, 'cause we've got all this worldbuilding, but not a lot of history? I think? ... But, that's what Gen0's for. So, it'll be fun to wait and piece together histories and stuff?
The entire DC Universe is one, while the real cities exist, all the heroes are in made up cities. In a lot of online fiction, authors make up business. People go to Burger Queen, Dairy King, Pizza Shack, McRonalds, etc. You don't see this in Pro books, because the authors know that unless they write something libelous, the companies aren't going to do anything.
Write that Walmart is putting subliminal messages to buy more stuff, and you are likely to get sued. Write that Ed went and bought some aspirin at Walmart, and they are happy for the free advertising.
As for Whateley history, except for a few points, the history is basically the same. WWII had some supers on each side, but that didn't change the outcome. I think the biggest difference is what happened on 9/11. Wallachia, Karadonia, and Paradise Island exists, but those are relatively minor things on a planetary scale.
Don't Drick and Drive.
- Malady
-
Valentine wrote:
Malady wrote:
elrodw wrote:
Valentine wrote: One thing I should have mentioned before. Thanks for using real places.
I really don't care for stories that are unwilling to use real places. The addition of minor things like Dunwich and Whateley's don't count, they still go to Boston, NYC, LA, etc. It's one of things that I don't like about DC Comics.
Glad you like that. I have a problem writing a place that doesn't feel or seem 'real'. It's more work, but using real places give me access to details to flesh out the setting. It's nice to know that people notice and appreciate the extra effort.
As a light comic reader? Or a reader of webcomics that aren't made to seem like the modern day, the use of real locales is invisible? But, now that I notice it, it's pretty nice! Same with the worldbuilding! It makes it seem more 'real'.
Edit: Oh, Valentine, you specified stories in general... I'm finding it hard to think of stories that are modern-day-ish, and are set on Earths, but use made-up places, and aren't set in a isolated area...
Fanfic-er's rant? [ Click to expand ] [ Click to hide ]... if a real pain to make Alt Hist. for, with sufficiently large Points of Divergence, 'cause we've got all this worldbuilding, but not a lot of history? I think? ... But, that's what Gen0's for. So, it'll be fun to wait and piece together histories and stuff?
The entire DC Universe is one, while the real cities exist, all the heroes are in made up cities. In a lot of online fiction, authors make up business. People go to Burger Queen, Dairy King, Pizza Shack, McRonalds, etc. You don't see this in Pro books, because the authors know that unless they write something libelous, the companies aren't going to do anything.
Write that Walmart is putting subliminal messages to buy more stuff, and you are likely to get sued. Write that Ed went and bought some aspirin at Walmart, and they are happy for the free advertising.
Oh, right. Bland Name Products and stuff, like in Anime. I guess it might be different in Japan?
Valentine wrote: As for Whateley history, except for a few points, the history is basically the same. WWII had some supers on each side, but that didn't change the outcome. I think the biggest difference is what happened on 9/11. Wallachia, Karadonia, and Paradise Island exists, but those are relatively minor things on a planetary scale.
Oh. Right. Yeah, I might be overthinking things... Wait... No, I'd be altering whole governmental organizations, and putting in things like a magical police system... Perhaps I'm not. I keep forgetting the scope of what I'm doing...
- Mister D
-
Is this the bear reference?
Measure Twice
- elrodw
-
Topic Author
Mister D wrote: There was a scene in "RoadHouse", where a member of the Bad Guy Gang, gets trapped underneath a a full size taxidermied polar bear.
Is this the bear reference?
"Very good, Fisher. You win a cookie."
(bonus point if you can tell me what movie that quote is from and who said it.)
Never give up, Never surrender! Captain Peter Quincy Taggert
- Valentine
-
Malady wrote:
Valentine wrote:
Malady wrote:
elrodw wrote:
Valentine wrote: One thing I should have mentioned before. Thanks for using real places.
I really don't care for stories that are unwilling to use real places. The addition of minor things like Dunwich and Whateley's don't count, they still go to Boston, NYC, LA, etc. It's one of things that I don't like about DC Comics.
Glad you like that. I have a problem writing a place that doesn't feel or seem 'real'. It's more work, but using real places give me access to details to flesh out the setting. It's nice to know that people notice and appreciate the extra effort.
As a light comic reader? Or a reader of webcomics that aren't made to seem like the modern day, the use of real locales is invisible? But, now that I notice it, it's pretty nice! Same with the worldbuilding! It makes it seem more 'real'.
Edit: Oh, Valentine, you specified stories in general... I'm finding it hard to think of stories that are modern-day-ish, and are set on Earths, but use made-up places, and aren't set in a isolated area...
Fanfic-er's rant? [ Click to expand ] [ Click to hide ]... if a real pain to make Alt Hist. for, with sufficiently large Points of Divergence, 'cause we've got all this worldbuilding, but not a lot of history? I think? ... But, that's what Gen0's for. So, it'll be fun to wait and piece together histories and stuff?
The entire DC Universe is one, while the real cities exist, all the heroes are in made up cities. In a lot of online fiction, authors make up business. People go to Burger Queen, Dairy King, Pizza Shack, McRonalds, etc. You don't see this in Pro books, because the authors know that unless they write something libelous, the companies aren't going to do anything.
Write that Walmart is putting subliminal messages to buy more stuff, and you are likely to get sued. Write that Ed went and bought some aspirin at Walmart, and they are happy for the free advertising.
Oh, right. Bland Name Products and stuff, like in Anime. I guess it might be different in Japan?
Valentine wrote: As for Whateley history, except for a few points, the history is basically the same. WWII had some supers on each side, but that didn't change the outcome. I think the biggest difference is what happened on 9/11. Wallachia, Karadonia, and Paradise Island exists, but those are relatively minor things on a planetary scale.
Oh. Right. Yeah, I might be overthinking things... Wait... No, I'd be altering whole governmental organizations, and putting in things like a magical police system... Perhaps I'm not. I keep forgetting the scope of what I'm doing...
Remember that there is a Presidential Adviser on Magical Affairs, I don't think it is a Cabinet level position, but that was not explained. Seems like it is equivalent to the National Security Advisor. As for a "Magical Police Dept.," I would think that given the low numbers of wizards, it might be part of the FBI, or given J. Edgar Hoover a separate Agency. NYC, LA, and Chicago might have a handful of investigators, maybe some of the bigger State Police Departments might have the same.
Don't Drick and Drive.
- peter
-
Astrodragon wrote:
mhalpern wrote:
Valentine wrote: Sooooooooooo, how do you get Amelie to Whateley?
possibly in an aircraft were all the electronics are in Faraday cages saving the com systems.
Or by ship...
could you not put her in the Faraday cage? A nice comfortable one mind you.
- peter
-
Kristin Darken wrote:
mmHmm. It makes me wonder how these people survive reading regular published material, honestly. Where they can't just throw a quick post off on a comment page demanding that someone fix that blaring error. That ONE horrible, torturous error. That didn't prevent the moment from being understood. Because, you know... its killing them to know that there's an improper usage of a special case of possessive adjective somewhere on the internet.And in print media... there's no one to complain to!??!!elrodw wrote: Thanks, asshole.
At least this one made a nice post about the story before their OCD got the best of them.
You should check out "MLP, Friendship is Magic, Season Six, Episode Thirteen" Just came out. Takes place at a Fan-con, and they have a character called Quibble Pants. I think you can figure out what sort he is.
"I only regard the first three Daring Do books as Canon. Everything after that was trash."
Some say it's a shout out to Star War's fandom.^_^
PS, they actually have a cut out of a pony version of Ranma in front of one booth. A lot of the MLP voice actors did the English Version of Ranma.
- peter
-
Dreamer wrote:
Ah, missed the miniatures from Night at the Museum part in that scene, should had have remembered a similar scene from the movie. Did note Asterix, Obelix, and Getafix in my comments, hard to forget a helmet like Asterix's once you've seen it and love the reference to him and his friends. I need to start watching out for more easter eggs like that in stories from now on, fun to figure them out and see the Whateley characters interact with such things from pop culture, etc.elrodw wrote: it's safe to assume that the dino skeleton was like a small (2m) allosaurus.
The reveal of the day:
The tiny figures are a joint homage to Asterix and Obelix, and the miniatures in Night at the Museum. The specific figures called out are:
the short one with winged helmet - Asterix.
the tall fat one in blue and white striped pants - Obelix.
the tall skinny one with very long beard - (not, it's NOT Galdalf!) Getafix the druid.
I've been reading a lot of Christopher Nuttall lately. He's a big E-book author. Incredible output. he loves to drop pop culture references into his works. I've seen him give sly shout outs to Asterix in three or four stories.
- Schol-R-LEA
-
Out, damnéd Spot! Bad Doggy!