Question Wiki Wiki Wiki!
- Sir Lee
-
- Malady
-
Sir Lee wrote: It might work. Do you want to submit a proposal?
Well, we've got some obvious choices for things to boilerplate and where to apply them, like Students Pages, as a subset of Characters Pages, and Character Pages is a really big one.
I'll use Aquerna's Page fused with Glow's Page as my example:
Headers:
MID
General description
Powers
Skills
Personality
Weaknesses
Notes
Appearances
Classes
Associations
Remove bits when non-applicable. And should be more like White Lady's page when info's lacking.
But perhaps the most important one is Story Pages...
Headers:
Story by Part:
Parts
Characters by Part:
Parts
Powers Pages might be boilerplated/standardized a bit after we get more info or something?
- Sir Lee
-
- mittfh
-
Topic Author
If the author of that page is reading this, this thread's an appropriate place to discuss their research so we can work on getting something more Wiki-friendly and verifiable.
As the right side of the brain controls the left side of the body, then only left-handers are in their right mind!
- Valentine
-
mittfh wrote: Meanwhile this anonymously added page has been added - do we know for sure all 73 characters are due to appear in the first two terms of AY 2007-08 and will be featured? Some sources would have helped - especially considering Josie Gillman's likely to be on a bus unless/until Drunkfu returns to the fold.
If the author of that page is reading this, this thread's an appropriate place to discuss their research so we can work on getting something more Wiki-friendly and verifiable.
Considering that list has "Daniel Franks" and "Daneille Franks" both listed, I doubt it is accurate. So unless a TINCC member speaks up, I say Shenanigans.
PS It's also missing Shine, and Lexi, Beth, and Victory from A Tenuous Blade.
Don't Drick and Drive.
- elrodw
-
(throws yellow flag sporting a drawing of a male bovine and a heap of steaming meadow muffins ....)
Excess Bullshit in the Wiki Entry.
15 yard penalty, loss of down!
Never give up, Never surrender! Captain Peter Quincy Taggert
- Valentine
-
elrodw wrote: TWEEEEEEET
(throws yellow flag sporting a drawing of a male bovine and a heap of steaming meadow muffins ....)
Excess Bullshit in the Wiki Entry.
15 yard penalty, loss of down!
Well that seems to be a definitive answer.
Don't Drick and Drive.
- DanZilla
-
There are also a good percentage of the characters listed that are fan-fiction.
- Sir Lee
-
- Nuuan
-
- lighttech
-
as a fan fic author
it should stay, as a great list of off site (WA-site) for now fan fic of that year in question.
just edit it into sections of
canon
TBA canon
maybe canon
and fan fic
as someone out there worked real hard
all it needs is the links to the characters in question on that list?
it would help the fan fic authors not on WA yet to get out there and seen?
just so you know 2 of them are mine and at least 4 others are those of authors I work with.
Part of the WA Drow clan/ collective
Author of Vantier and Shadowsblade on Bigcloset
- Kristin Darken
-
Fate guard you and grant you a Light to brighten your Way.
- lighttech
-
the list has to start somewhere? and this seems like a good place.
I would bet whoever placed it there, will be back and if Sir Lee puts a note on it asking for the posters info and the list to be more complete. There is a high chance it will get done.
like all the stories here it had to start somewhere?
Part of the WA Drow clan/ collective
Author of Vantier and Shadowsblade on Bigcloset
- Sir Lee
-
The main reason for the deletion is that... well, it just didn't fit. It was a list of names assembled in a somewhat haphazard way. It included non-canon characters. It didn't follow any particular rationale (such as, "class of 2011" for instance). It would take considerable work to cleanup and research references just to get it nearer usefulness. It simply wasn't in an encyclopedia-like form.
And then, "list" pages are a pain. Just ask the brave souls who maintain the Character and Story lists. Whenever a list can be generated automatically (like in a Category), we are better off using those.
If someone wants a copy of that page for use as help into, say, adding stuff the the "Current students list" or "Characters list" pages, I'm pasting it below. I might also post it to the "Character list" talk page.
FALL/WINTER 2007
* Amy nee Austin Maguire, Roulette
* Alyss Megan Morgan, Ribbon
* Martina Hughes, Knockoff
* Stacy Conrad, Silver Ghost
* Lille Skygge, LITTLE SHADOW
* Melanie Shino Mikokami, Keres
* Melissa Chambers, Mischief
* Evan Ramsey, several energy-manipulation abilities
* Josie Gillman, non-Euclidean concepts and magic
* Ethan Anders_Camille Anders,
* Seraphina Sophia "Fina" Valocco, Envy
* ++ Achmed-Deluge
* ++ Justice-Spear of Tseode
* ++ Tim-Cúpiní-k'áplac
* ++ Jules-Cúpiní-teqè's
* ++ Cassie-Chira
* Anna, a 14 year old devisor;
* Jasmine, a 16 year old manifestor;
* Rene, a 16 year old energiser
* Hans, a 15 year old PK brick
* Beam-Beam or BB, a mid level energiser blaster;
* A-Man, a TK-Superman,
* Strongbow, high level exemplar with the full PDP package
* Highball, a mid level sidhe type mage/empath
* Deborah, a gadgeteer
* Krystal, stretcher, a type of shape-shifter
* Jennifer, a Technopath Gadgeteer/Devisor
* Pamela, a size warper
* Julie Robinson codename
* Daniel Franks, avatar
* Rachael Merrick, GLOW
* Erin Frank Danielson, Esoteric
* Maxine Granger, IRONWORKS, Lodestone
* Rose Campbell,
* victoria smith,
* Minerva Campbell, Mneme
* Michael Christopher Henderson, Silver-Drake
* Atalanta Rose Reed, Equal - (Paladin)
* Kelly Moira Kontos,
* Leah Ephraim Cook, Terra
* Fiona Siobhan McCloud, Luna
* Rohanna Leigh, Shadows Blade
* Kyley Barron, Vantier
* Star Spark, energy being
* Michelle Molesly, Fractal
* Alyssa VanBuren, Kudzu
* Gwendolynn Wylann, Absinthe
* Melody Romsey, Mirage Rose
* MJ Sparks, gadgeteer, energizer
* Joan Brown, Timeout
* Ezra Fallingbird, Exemplar 2. Wizard 4. Reality Warper 4b (r/p/d)
* Annette Swenson, Fadeaway
* Daneille Franks, Shapeshifter
* Eden William Oakson, Mage
* Asuna Hinato, Reimei
* Kim Carter, Shogo
* Kestra Wallace, Pixie
* Marie Bandsma, Pushover
* Pat Miller, Empath
* Andrea, gravitational warper
* crystalline, gadgeteer or devisor
* Isabelle, Porcelain
* Constance "Connie" Sutherland, Flying Fox - flying, strength, PK, force fields
* Dorothy Gayle (D'artagnan "Art" Gayle), Blip - warper (teleportation) ESP (clairvoyance?)
* Donald "Don" Sutherland, Bishounen - EX-1?, ESP-2
* Allison "Alice" Sutherland, Lolicon - EX-2?, ESP-2
* Rachel Stein, Galatea - Exemplar 3/4
* Roberto (Bobby), Roughhouse - Exemplar 5, Regen 3
* Rick, Dune - Exemplar 3, Manifestor 1c (sand), Regen 1, Warper 1e
* Rhonda, Path - PDP 3/2/3 (Empathy, Telepathy, non-ranged TK) ESP -1
* Maria, Shockflash - Exemplar - 3, Regen - 1, Energizer 3(mixed)
* Braith Brice, Defensor - Avatar-3, Regen-3, TK -3D
* Faith Marshall, MERCY
- Astrodragon
-

I love watching their innocent little faces smiling happily as they trip gaily down the garden path, before finding the pit with the rusty spikes.
- Phoenix Spiritus
-
Astrodragon wrote: Hmm, is it worth doing a separate list labelled 'Elrod's Chew Toys'?
That one's easy:
"All of Creation!"
There, done!
- Valentine
-
Astrodragon wrote: Hmm, is it worth doing a separate list labelled 'Elrod's Chew Toys'?
That would best be a category.
Don't Drick and Drive.
- lighttech
-
then add the "talk" note?
it took me near a month of reading and using the WA wiki till I even really noticed the thing? Perhaps the poster is in the same boat?
I sure hope this dose not dissuade someone who tired to help?
on another note can someone who knows that wiki better grab up all that info and clean it up so that maybe we can have links to other great fan fics off the WA page?
Part of the WA Drow clan/ collective
Author of Vantier and Shadowsblade on Bigcloset
- DanZilla
-
lighttech wrote: ohh well I had hoped you at least keep it up the week as it was posted on a weekend and maybe the person who did can only get back to it on such dates?
then add the "talk" note?
it took me near a month of reading and using the WA wiki till I even really noticed the thing? Perhaps the poster is in the same boat?
I sure hope this dose not dissuade someone who tired to help?
on another note can someone who knows that wiki better grab up all that info and clean it up so that maybe we can have links to other great fan fics off the WA page?
Well... it's not gone completely... he put the text into the spoiler tag of his post above... it DID need to come down though since it was so misleading due to the mixed canon and fanfic content. Without some serious editing it would have been severely misleading to visitors to the wiki who don't know where these characters came from and expected them to be canon and couldn't find them or who had read them as fanfic and now thought they had been adopted into canon.
As fans of ALL the canon AND fanfic authors out there it IS a shame for it to have to be removed but it's only since we don't want to see that confusion.
Perhaps we should see if allowing for a fanfiction category for stories should be something that people Could and would contribute to... not for their characters and info but just for the stories themselves... and always defaulting to fan-fiction hosted on whateleyacademy.net if more than one version is hosted on different sites. Not that I don't want to see people directed to other sites but since this is the home of the Whateley Academy canon stories it should have preference in the wiki.
- lighttech
-
Perhaps we should see if allowing for a fanfiction category for stories should be something that people Could and would contribute to... not for their characters and info but just for the stories themselves... and always defaulting to fan-fiction hosted on whateleyacademy.net if more than one version is hosted on different sites. Not that I don't want to see people directed to other sites but since this is the home of the Whateley Academy canon stories it should have preference in the wiki.[/quote]
I could go for this IF? fan fic was not so hard to get posted here in its complete form
As I know you can post 10k sections one at a time in the fan fic section----but getting a fan fic listed here, involves JUMPING thorough BIG hoops.
and some of those are
editing--- some of us can't find a good editor that has time...and that includes me.
time --some of us want to spend time....writing, not editing every little thing?
Part of the WA Drow clan/ collective
Author of Vantier and Shadowsblade on Bigcloset
- DanZilla
-
lighttech wrote:
DanZilla wrote: Perhaps we should see if allowing for a fanfiction category for stories should be something that people Could and would contribute to... not for their characters and info but just for the stories themselves... and always defaulting to fan-fiction hosted on whateleyacademy.net if more than one version is hosted on different sites. Not that I don't want to see people directed to other sites but since this is the home of the Whateley Academy canon stories it should have preference in the wiki.
I could go for this IF? fan fic was not so hard to get posted here in its complete form
As I know you can post 10k sections one at a time in the fan fic section----but getting a fan fic listed here, involves JUMPING thorough BIG hoops.
and some of those are
editing--- some of us can't find a good editor that has time...and that includes me.
time --some of us want to spend time....writing, not editing every little thing?
I think you misunderstand me... just posting fan fiction on this site doesn't require any hoop-jumping... just writing it and posting it in the appropriate forum... I'm not advocating stories listed as I mentioned be in the official fan fiction section on the site... just posted in the forums.
- lighttech
-
posting to the open fan fic section. one of my 140k fan fics in little 10 k chunks would take a week?
and I hate to do that..as I like my stories complete to a point?
the hoops I talk about, is posting the whole thing to the library fan fic shelf...so to say?
Part of the WA Drow clan/ collective
Author of Vantier and Shadowsblade on Bigcloset
- Phoenix Spiritus
-
I think we need to get a little more organised in the Fan-Fiction section, see how many people are interested in helping and what they are interested in doing, and how we can make it easiest to help. I know putting stories into the official Fan-Fiction section is much easier then into the forums, but we still need a way for "incomplete" stories to be worked on and reviewed before we elevate them to the "Official" section.
I mean, the process does work, "Two Become One (Part 1)" is very different from its original status, but it came up to speck and was published through (admittedly) hard work by Pioneer.
My own "So Shalt Thou Show Me Friendship" is also radically different to the way it was first written, through comments and suggestions from the Fan-Fiction group, good enough that Kristin has written it might be moved to canon status.
So the process is working, we (the Fan-Fiction authors and those willing to help us) just need to step up start fully owning the process and getting some more frameworks going to support each other.
I'm not the best editor (after all my work migrating stories from the old site, I'm probably a much better copywriter by now), but I'm happy to help lighttech if you would like me too.
- Sir Lee
-
The thing is, even if cleaned up, that list form does not lend itself well to be incorporated into the wiki. We avoid having hand-built lists, because they are a bitch to maintain.
Yes, we do have a stories list, because -- while we could do a basic listing with category:stories, it wouldn't give any info regarding suggested reading order(s), which is a big deal for new readers.
And yes, we do have character lists... although I wasn't a fan of them at first, precisely because they are a bitch to maintain... but they ended up being an useful repository for characters who don't have their own pages (yet). Just having them there, with basic info such as story they appeared and a five-word description, can help. And lots of times this is the *only* place the character is being redlinked from -- that is, it's the one thing that ensures the character gets inserted into the "wanted pages" listing.
But, the way that list was proposed... it wasn't useful enough. It would be better to just incorporate the data (the valid parts, that is) into the Student List page. But I was not able to see a rationale to keep that page, even after cleaning up it.
And yes, I do regret not being able to explain this to the (doubtlessly well-meaning) contributor who posted the page, and talk about other ways to contribute. That's the problem with anonymous contributions.
As for fanfics... we do have pages for a couple which are particularly notable. We conceivably could add more, although I'm the wrong person to do that (I don't read many fanfics, so I have no idea which ones would deserve wiki mention). I would prefer to keep those pages somewhat insulated from the main wiki, however; thus, no sharing of the categories, no linking from canon to non-canon, very little linking from non-canon to canon...
Note that a few fanfic authors should be getting their own pages, because they have made some sort of canon contribution, like the Combat Finals. We may have to think of a new category system for authors. It used to be easy when there was just the TINCC. Now we have the Gen1 CC, the Gen2 CC (who does not have access to the Gen1 Bible), Gen2 writers contributing to Gen1, outside writers contributing to either, and the Gen0/Gen3 (I'm not sure if the name was settled) who may not even be a permanent group. Maybe "Authors" for the permanent members and "Contributors" for the occasional ones would be enough? Maybe "Guest Authors" instead of "Contributors"?
- Malady
-
Can you / Should you, make your Bot transform...
Nevermind.
Mindlessly Transforming Dates into links means that out-of-universe dates, like Upload Dates would be transformed too. ... Although, that could be mitigated with Real World and Whateley-Verse Sections. But too much work?
Same thing basically applies for locations, I think?
...
Catgirl Madness seems a bit link-dense, but once info is added, I guess it'll look less cluttered. ... Yeah... I'm gonna link locations too...
- Sir Lee
-
And, really, since we lost our timeline maintainer, (Please, Xaltatun, come back! We miss you!), most of those links are sorta... dead. I would rate as higher priority to take care of the timeline pages so we have something to link TO, rather than adding more links to nonexistent pages.
- mittfh
-
Topic Author
Sir Lee wrote: (Please, Xaltatun, come back! We miss you!)
Hello there - he has posted to several threads but appears to have been afk for a couple of weeks. Maybe in time we can gently guide him back to the Wiki...

As for sorting out that mess of a character list, if there are several who'd like to collaborate on using it as inspiration for a better list (e.g. Canon, subdivided into Full POV / POV Insert / Background / On a bus / Unknown) I could open up a Google doc and share the edit link - I wouldn't do much editing myself (I don't have much time to spare each evening - hence why it usually takes nearly a week to update the various lists of Canon Stories), but it would be somewhere you could use as a collaborative environment suited to easy editing without worrying about formatting (as I'd hope any final iteration would serve as inspiration for a Wiki page rather than forming the basis of it) without the world + dog looking in.
As the right side of the brain controls the left side of the body, then only left-handers are in their right mind!
- Kristin Darken
-
editing--- some of us can't find a good editor that has time...and that includes me.
time --some of us want to spend time....writing, not editing every little thing?
Here's the thing that people don't seem to get. Being recognized as canon or having a story made canon means something to this community because it takes work and performance up to certain standards to get posted. The fan fiction system works the same way. It means something only if it is something that takes more effort than just having a random unique idea and vomiting it onto the page. If EVERYONE can do it, then no one will care about it.
We've added a number of options that open up the possibility for people to become canon or get stories canonized this past year. But one of the appeals to the WU has always been that whether you like the story/plot or not, that it will be decently written. We have our flops, but we still try to keep the standards up ... and the readership counts on that. There's no plan to change that.
Fate guard you and grant you a Light to brighten your Way.
- Domoviye
-
lighttech wrote: As I know you can post 10k sections one at a time in the fan fic section----but getting a fan fic listed here, involves JUMPING thorough BIG hoops.
and some of those are
editing--- some of us can't find a good editor that has time...and that includes me.
time --some of us want to spend time....writing, not editing every little thing?
Tidy it up and post it in the fanfic section for people to edit. As others have said we're working out kinks and bugs, but it will get edited by some people and then you just have to consider their suggestions and make any necessary changes.
- Sir Lee
-
crystalhall.wikia.com/wiki/CHARCTER_PAGE
- Kristin Darken
-
Fate guard you and grant you a Light to brighten your Way.
- Sir Lee
-
- Yeah, it's the same IP as the previous "misguided contribution," 68.0.145.94. This same IP had two edits last year, which Baby Valentine promptly reverted. Four edits, four mistakes... it's looking bad.
Admittedly, it could be a coincidence and three different cox.net subscribers made miguided, anonymous edits to the wiki. But somehow, I don't think so. It appears to be the same person. Funny that their IP hasn't changed since September... I thought most ISPs kinda forced periodic IP changes on their subscribers in order to be able to charge extra for a fixed IP.
- Kristin Darken
-
Fate guard you and grant you a Light to brighten your Way.
- Sir Lee
-
- Malady
-
We should have made the "Layouts"... Like talked about here:
crystalhall.wikia.com/wiki/Help:New_page
Decide between a standard page layout or a blank page. The standard layout provides image and video placeholders as well as section headings. The preload contents for the "Standard layout" are stored at MediaWiki:Createpage-with-video on your wikia and can be edited by local admins.
- Sir Lee
-
EDIT: I'm not sure that we can customize it. The help page claims that "local admins" should be able to edit the standard layout page, but it didn't let me -- and I'm both an Administrator and a Bureaucrat for the wiki. Too bad, it would have been nice.
I guess "local admins" actually means the Wikia corporate admins... that help page might have been a slightly edited version from the standard MediaWiki package, which is geared towards single-wiki setups and doesn't really make distinctions between "admin" and "wiki admin."
- mittfh
-
Topic Author
* Kayda 8 p01, Lapin 1 p02, Glyph 1 p03, Glyph 1 p04 added.
* Sappho renamed Kayda 5
* Kayda 5 renamed Kayda 6
* Kayda 6 renamed Kayda 7
Currently Lapin 1 sits in Uncertain Dated Stories due to the lack of internal dates. It's likely the framing narrative can be dated (5th Sep, start of Calamari?), so we might be able to move it up to Dated Stories based on the date of the framing narrative rather than the origin itself.
Oh, and if someone could sanity check the Canon Stories by Release Date do link to the relevant pages / entries and have the correct short code (i.e. Name # p##) I'd be grateful - with three different destination pages, plus the differences between link location (i.e. Page Name#Date) and link text (i.e. Date), there is the potential for errors to creep in and I'd rather a second pair of eyes double checks I haven't made any foul-ups

As the right side of the brain controls the left side of the body, then only left-handers are in their right mind!
- Sir Lee
-
- mittfh
-
Topic Author
As Gen 0 is likely to be expanded on in future, I thought it might be a good idea - besides which, as well as A Good Man, we've also got Baker's Dozen, The Island of Dr. DNA and The Backside of Paradise set in Gen 0 (so trimming the top end of the table on the G1 Y1 page).
As the right side of the brain controls the left side of the body, then only left-handers are in their right mind!
- elrodw
-
Never give up, Never surrender! Captain Peter Quincy Taggert
- Phoenix Spiritus
-

- mittfh
-
Topic Author
elrodw wrote: has anyone run the statistics lately?
Good point - I haven't updated the spreadsheet since G2 dropped - I'll sort it out over the next
Ta da!
Most of the tabs should be fairly self-explanatory - let me know if you don't understand anything

Stories: 225
Episodes: 413
Words: 9,017,959
Words to 10 million: 982,041
Gen 0 Words: 52,137
Gen 1 Words: 8,633,748
Gen 2 Words: 223,142
Unclassified Words: 108,932
Author combinations: 49
Unique first authorss: 25
All unique authors: 32
Unclassified: Envy and the Gilded Cage (no internal dates, so when's it set?), Razzle Dazzle (framing narrative set in Gen 1, remainder set in Gen 0 - so is it Gen 0 or Gen 1?!)
As the right side of the brain controls the left side of the body, then only left-handers are in their right mind!
- Domoviye
-
mittfh wrote: There's now yet another page in the ever-expanding number of pages containing lists of Canon Stories: Dated Stories - Generation Zero
As Gen 0 is likely to be expanded on in future, I thought it might be a good idea - besides which, as well as A Good Man, we've also got Baker's Dozen, The Island of Dr. DNA and The Backside of Paradise set in Gen 0 (so trimming the top end of the table on the G1 Y1 page).
I'm too busy to do the editing, but I have basic outlines for the characters and story A Good Man, that would fit the Wiki, who wants to post it?
- Kristin Darken
-
So there is no point in creating a separate timeline for tracking Gen 0 stories.... as each story will be fairly stand alone and outside the other timelines. For example... A Good Man is early 1990's... another of them is 1920's... a third in the 1980's.... one possibility is the mid 2020's and so forth.
Fate guard you and grant you a Light to brighten your Way.
- Valentine
-
Don't Drick and Drive.
- mittfh
-
Topic Author
Technically, we've got several Gen0 stories already - A Good Man, Island of Dr. DNA / Backside of Paradise and Baker's Dozen with firm dates, plus Razzle Dazzle (framing narrative set in 2007, Mephisto's tales set throughout the preceeding decades) and Forging Anew (pre-Sundering) which can't be definitively pinned down. Currently, Envy sits with them as it has no internal dates - if/when Dr. B writes a sequel or we get WoG on when it takes place (don't need to be any more specific than AY), it can be moved onto the relevant page.
The numerous Lists of Canon Stories on the Wiki are mainly for convenient collections of stories rather than strict timelines - hence the majority are arranged by Academic Year (including the origins for characters starting Whateley in that AY, which of course would in most cases would take place the prior AY). Gen0 as a convenient grab-bag for tales outside the main continuity makes sense in that context. Fling's an edge case - currently in G1 as although their 'real life' events so far haven't involved anyone at Whateley, their GEO adventures have had tangentially intertwined with GEO adventures of Whateley students (mainly in the GEO Vignettes round robin).
As the right side of the brain controls the left side of the body, then only left-handers are in their right mind!
- Phoenix Spiritus
-
It would cause confusion if the Wiki has a "Gen 0" section which includes stories that are not the Canon definition of "Gen 0". May I suggest the Wiki just has an "Other Canon Stories" section which includes all those stores that are not Gen 1 or Gen 2, but are canon can be grouped? And that the Gen 0 stories are added to that section (if they can't be considered Gen 1 or Gen 2 stories).
- Sir Lee
-
- mittfh
-
Topic Author
Intro now changed to : This page lists all the Whateley Academy stories that take place outside the main continuity - this could be pre-Generation 1, post-Generation 2, or even background stories set within the timespan of the main continuity.
Now to rename the links pointing to the stories on that page before Sir Lee deletes the redirect

P.S. On the main Canon Stories page, it's perhaps wise to rename "out-of-continuity" (the author interviews) to something else ("Meta-canon"?) to avoid confusion...
P.P.S. Is there WoG on when Envy takes place? There aren't any internal dates, so it would be helpful to know where it should sit

As the right side of the brain controls the left side of the body, then only left-handers are in their right mind!
- Sir Lee
-
mittfh wrote: Now to rename the links pointing to the stories on that page before Sir Lee deletes the redirect
Done! You had missed just one link from the main page... the redirects are no more. Kaput. They are ex-redirects.
By the way, if you ever get faced with a similar situation -- fixing links to avoid a redirect, after a page rename -- just drop me a message. This is exactly the sort of job for which the AutoWikiBrowser is great, and I went to all the trouble of setting it up and everything...
(If anybody else wants to set up a bot, I can help, a little. But it's a bit of a bureaucratic process, because the special bot permissions can only be given by the Wikia staff, not by the admins)
- elrodw
-

Never give up, Never surrender! Captain Peter Quincy Taggert
- Domoviye
-
Between two jobs, and editing the second draft of A Good Man I haven't even looked at Wiki except to clarify a few details.
- Sir Lee
-
- elrodw
-
Sir Lee wrote: ...nearing the "do-or-forget-about-it" deadline for upgrading machines to Windows 10...
Don't you mean "downgrading" or "degrading" machines to Windows 10?

Never give up, Never surrender! Captain Peter Quincy Taggert
- Sir Lee
-
But for anyone stuck with the trainwreck that was Win8, Windows 10 has hardly any downsides. Just turn off the bunch of snooping "features" M$ added to it.
But even if you see no improvement at all, I still recommend people do the update to Win10. Do it, and if you don't like it, revert to the old version right away. That's enough to register your product key as "valid for Windows 10" in Microsoft's servers; if in one or two years, you find a good reason to move to Win10, you won't have to pay retail for it.
- rubberjohn
-
From my point of view each new edition of Windows becomes more bloated with stuff that I don't actually want or use and takes longer and longer to actually start working when I start up each day. However as I'm not a coding expert I'm stuck with what's available on the machines when I buy them! Windows does work, after all!
John.
- mittfh
-
Topic Author
On the computer front, I sit smugly when hearing tales of woe of Windoze Updates - I'm running Arch Linux, which (unlike many flavours) doesn't have built-in automatic updates, instead relying on its users to run updates as/when (and is a rolling release, so doesn't have a set update schedule - new components are released as/when available - hence why they recommend it not be used on production systems). The developers also don't mind users doing eccentric stuff such as installing and running components from multiple different desktop environments simultaneously (in my case, Xfce + KDE's Kwin + Cinnamon's Nemo + MATE's System Monitor and Pluma text editor) - as long as if something goes wrong, they can actually state what they were doing at the time and upload relevant logs etc.
(Hmm...it's been a while... sudo pacman -Syu --> 143 updated/upgraded packages, totalling 463.44 MiB)
As the right side of the brain controls the left side of the body, then only left-handers are in their right mind!
- mittfh
-
Topic Author
There's a whole bunch of redlinks to characters who haven't been created yet - I've probably gone a bit overboard with the listed PoVs, including many who just have significant amounts of speaking time, and while I could have substituted The Amazons and Venus Inc. for the individual members' names, putting all the names in creates an incentive to start creating character pages

[EDIT]That infernal spreadsheet has now been updated.
In the story rankings, Bek's still way ahead of everyone with 36 tales, while EE and Diane are tied for second with 22 each. Elrod ranks sixth (13 tales), with Morpheus coming in at eighth (11 tales).
Diane still leads the word count with over 1.6 million words (19% of canon), with Bek coming in second with 1.4 million (nearly 16%) and Elrod a distant third with 675,000 (just over 7½%), while Morpheus is sixth with a smidgen under ½ million words (just over 5½%).
Interestingly, top spot for the longest average story length (total words / number of stories) is a double-act... the EEEs (EE Nalley + ElrodW), while the combined G2 canon (i.e. Calamari authors) come in at seventh.
In terms of episodes, Diane (76) and Bek (54) take the top two spots, while the EEEs come joint third (32 each) and Morpheus sixth (24). The word count will differ from that of the story word count in a few places, due to some tales whose author roster changes for specific parts / chapters, but should be broadly similar, while in Words Per Installment, Sleethr comes in fourth.
As the right side of the brain controls the left side of the body, then only left-handers are in their right mind!
- Malady
-
Or do we?
Info to scrape and add:
whateleyacademy.net/index.php/forum/revi...out-magic-sorta#3906
- Malady
-
Or is that either impossible, or a bad idea??
Could such a link checking based idea at least be applied to fill the list of appearances for each character? Like the story list in the Phase article?
***
Do we have almost an article for every Gen1 student?? 'Cause IIRC, there's ~500-600 students, and we have around that number of Gen1 student articles?
- Sir Lee
-
Hmm. Interesting question. I'll have to look into the AutoWikiBrowser docs to see if there's any practical way to do it.Malady wrote: @Sir Lee - You know those empty date pages? Is there some automated thing you could do, like find all the inbound links and filling the pages with the paragraphs that are right after the links?
Or is that either impossible, or a bad idea??
Let me think... even if it has to be applied manually, some sort of basic structure that could help? Like a template that generates a "What Links Here" list? Have to do more research.
That would probably be harder, because it would have to distinguish between story pages and other pages. I'm not sure if it's practical -- it would probably require custom programming.Malady wrote: Could such a link checking based idea at least be applied to fill the list of appearances for each character? Like the story list in the Phase article?
I think we are nearly complete as far as mentioned students go, yes. I would have to check the "wanted pages" list to see if there are any mentioned-but-still-pageless students. And there might be still a few students that haven't been mentioned anywhere.Malady wrote: Do we have almost an article for every Gen1 student?? 'Cause IIRC, there's ~500-600 students, and we have around that number of Gen1 student articles?
There are also probably still a few students with *more* than one page, in that they have been mentioned once by codename and another time by name and the association between both has not been made. ElrodW did some cleanup work by explicitly mentioning the association in story, but some of those reveals might not made into the Wiki yet.
And probably pretty soon we will have to worry about a whole batch of new students, as soon as the timeline advances into September...
- Malady
-
Sir Lee wrote:
Hmm. Interesting question. I'll have to look into the AutoWikiBrowser docs to see if there's any practical way to do it.Malady wrote: @Sir Lee - You know those empty date pages? Is there some automated thing you could do, like find all the inbound links and filling the pages with the paragraphs that are right after the links?
Or is that either impossible, or a bad idea??
Let me think... even if it has to be applied manually, some sort of basic structure that could help? Like a template that generates a "What Links Here" list? Have to do more research.
Well, you could manually copy-paste the Special:WhatLinksHere, for each page... In case you forgot about that...
Sir Lee wrote:
That would probably be harder, because it would have to distinguish between story pages and other pages. I'm not sure if it's practical -- it would probably require custom programming.Malady wrote: Could such a link checking based idea at least be applied to fill the list of appearances for each character? Like the story list in the Phase article?
Oh, you can't just check if it's in the Stories Category, then?
Sir Lee wrote:
I think we are nearly complete as far as mentioned students go, yes. I would have to check the "wanted pages" list to see if there are any mentioned-but-still-pageless students. And there might be still a few students that haven't been mentioned anywhere.Malady wrote: Do we have almost an article for every Gen1 student?? 'Cause IIRC, there's ~500-600 students, and we have around that number of Gen1 student articles?
Well, we now have 938 wanted pages, some of those are templates, like Template:X1 , at least ~100, I'd assume are dates, some are links that could be folded into others, like "All the King's Horses...", which I just folded into "All the King's Horses", and the rest are the other things we want.
Also, some dates aren't pure numbers, like May 14, 2007 instead of 2007-05-14.
Sir Lee wrote: There are also probably still a few students with *more* than one page, in that they have been mentioned once by codename and another time by name and the association between both has not been made. ElrodW did some cleanup work by explicitly mentioning the association in story, but some of those reveals might not made into the Wiki yet.
And probably pretty soon we will have to worry about a whole batch of new students, as soon as the timeline advances into September...
*nods*, Gonna take a look around...
- Sir Lee
-
I would prefer a template that embeds the "WhatLinksHere" results in the page itself. I have to research to see if that's possible.Malady wrote: Well, you could manually copy-paste the Special:WhatLinksHere, for each page... In case you forgot about that...
That would be the idea, but I have to see if templates actually allow for doing this sort of filtering to a "WhatLinksHere" result -- postulating that WhatLinksHere can be pulled by a template in the first place.Malady wrote: Oh, you can't just check if it's in the Stories Category, then?
Generating a static list of links with AWB might not be easy either.
That last will probably have to be fixed manually. But note that so far we only link dates when they are describing in-universe events. Story release dates and such other "real-world" events are usually left as regular text, since mixing the two could get confusing.Malady wrote: Well, we now have 938 wanted pages, some of those are templates, like Template:X1 , at least ~100, I'd assume are dates, some are links that could be folded into others, like "All the King's Horses...", which I just folded into "All the King's Horses", and the rest are the other things we want.
Also, some dates aren't pure numbers, like May 14, 2007 instead of 2007-05-14.
Any help is a big help.Malady wrote: *nods*, Gonna take a look around...
- Malady
-
www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Extension:CategoryIntersection
Or this one:
www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Extension:DynamicPageList_(Wikimedia)
- Valentine
-
Don't Drick and Drive.
- Malady
-
EDIT: And everyone with a note of "(real name unknown)", or some variant, into the Unknown Real Name Category?
- Valentine
-
Malady wrote: ... What am I doing?? ... Should we just add every student that's not in a Powers category into Unknown Powers?
EDIT: And everyone with a note of "(real name unknown)", or some variant, into the Unknown Real Name Category?
NOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Adding people with known powers is fine, but the other is a bit silly. A lot of those characters are just name drops. Someone saw them as they entered a building, or said "Hi" as they walked by. In some cases we know they live in a specific Cottage because that is where they were, but in others all we have is a name.
Don't Drick and Drive.
- Malady
-
Valentine wrote:
Malady wrote: ... What am I doing?? ... Should we just add every student that's not in a Powers category into Unknown Powers?
EDIT: And everyone with a note of "(real name unknown)", or some variant, into the Unknown Real Name Category?
NOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!

EDIT:
Adding people with known powers is fine, but the other is a bit silly. A lot of those characters are just name drops. Someone saw them as they entered a building, or said "Hi" as they walked by. In some cases we know they live in a specific Cottage because that is where they were, but in others all we have is a name.
Ah. Thank you for explaining.
***
There has been no cottage and no year of any cottage that's been filled to capacity, right? So we can't deduce the cottage of those who aren't in any cottage through process of elimination?
We also don't know enough of the student population's power sets to say that certain people have to be a certain power type 'else the population counts of users of each power is out of wack?
- Valentine
-
Malady wrote:
Valentine wrote:
Malady wrote: ... What am I doing?? ... Should we just add every student that's not in a Powers category into Unknown Powers?
EDIT: And everyone with a note of "(real name unknown)", or some variant, into the Unknown Real Name Category?
NOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!
... Are... you referencing something? ... If not, what's wrong with my suggestion?
EDIT:
Adding people with known powers is fine, but the other is a bit silly. A lot of those characters are just name drops. Someone saw them as they entered a building, or said "Hi" as they walked by. In some cases we know they live in a specific Cottage because that is where they were, but in others all we have is a name.
Ah. Thank you for explaining.
***
There has been no cottage and no year of any cottage that's been filled to capacity, right? So we can't deduce the cottage of those who aren't in any cottage through process of elimination?
We also don't know enough of the student population's power sets to say that certain people have to be a certain power type 'else the population counts of users of each power is out of wack?
2006-07 Student list
There is not enough information to fill any Cottage. The only floor we know completely is Poe Freshman, and we don't have room assignments for everyone there.
Don't Drick and Drive.
- Malady
-
Edit:
Place See Also after references? Or before, and leave references until the end? Well, it's not like it'll be a hard fix if I screw it up... Gonna follow Wikipedia and stick references at the end...
Edit2:
Is redirecting things back to the page they link from, in any way a good idea, if they're only linked from one location, or something, like Catherine Code and Mr. Cody, who are only linked from the Kodiak page...
- mittfh
-
Topic Author
Since the word counts are currently overall, but the author roster changes over time, I've now compiled words per author combination per year (WordsPerYear tab), both as raw numbers and percentages.
For 2016, the roster looks like this:
14.2% = Morpheus
12.2% = ElrodW, Nagrij
10.4% = ElrodW
09.2% = Nagrij
09.1% = ElrodW, E. E. Nalley, Morpheus, Bek D. Corbin, Kristin Darken, Neomagus, Domoviye
07.7% = E. E. Nalley
06.7% = Astrodragon, ElrodW, Kristin Darken, MageOhki, MaLAguA, Morpheus, Nagrij, NeoMagus, Souffle Girl, Wasamon
05.2% = Astrodragon
05.1% = Sleethr
03.9% = Bek D. Corbin, E. E. Nalley
03.5% = Phoenix Spiritus
03.3% = Bek D. Corbin
02.7% = Kristin Darken
02.3% = Domoviye
01.9% = Neomagus, ElrodW
01.3% = MageOhki
01.2% = Light-of-Fury (sponsored by ElrodW)
As the right side of the brain controls the left side of the body, then only left-handers are in their right mind!
- Malady
-
Whateley Wiki page: crystalhall.wikia.com/wiki/Gnostisophism?redirect=no
***
Is redirecting things back to the page they link from, in any way a good idea, if they're only linked from one location, or something, like Catherine Cody and Mr. Cody, who are only linked from the Kodiak page?
***
Also, should we link to Categories? 'Cause Cyberkitty wants Were and Cyberpath pages, but we have Were and Technopath Categories, with descriptions... But then again, Exemplar has both Category and Article versions... Perhaps make and redirect the pages into the categories for now?
Then again, we're at
- Valentine
-
Malady wrote: I can't find any info on Gnostisophism. Can anyone else?
Whateley Wiki page: crystalhall.wikia.com/wiki/Gnostisophism?redirect=no
***
Is redirecting things back to the page they link from, in any way a good idea, if they're only linked from one location, or something, like Catherine Cody and Mr. Cody, who are only linked from the Kodiak page?
I think you'll have to ask Bek about that one.
Don't Drick and Drive.
- Malady
-
- Sir Lee
-
- Valentine
-
Don't Drick and Drive.
- elrodw
-
Never give up, Never surrender! Captain Peter Quincy Taggert
- Malady
-
Also, we can confirm some students as not being Seniors due to their participation at the Halloween Dance. ... Yeah, gonna make them a category...
Is Ringo Class of 2010, or 2008? 2008. Legacy of Friendship has Timeless report that "Ringo is a junior and he is not in your second period History class."
- DanZilla
-
Malady wrote: Hmm... We have 140 students in the Class of 2010 Category. How many more can there be??
Are you assuming that all students who enter Whateley will stay there all four years? It can be assumed that the majority will... BUT there are always the fatalities, the ones who maybe drop out of school for various reasons on their own volition or that of outside forces and those who may not qualify for continued scholarship due to learning enough about their powers to not need to continue to attend.
- Malady
-
DanZilla wrote:
Malady wrote: Hmm... We have 140 students in the Class of 2010 Category. How many more can there be??
Are you assuming that all students who enter Whateley will stay there all four years? It can be assumed that the majority will... BUT there are always the fatalities, the ones who maybe drop out of school for various reasons on their own volition or that of outside forces and those who may not qualify for continued scholarship due to learning enough about their powers to not need to continue to attend.
Well there is that, but I'm wondering how many others have to go into that category until we can say "There are no students of Whateley Academy Class of 2010 that are unrecorded in the Wiki" ... Am I expecting an answer? Not really? Then shut up about it and let people figure it out for themselves? Hmm?
But as we have a cap on student counts for the year of 2006-2007 at like 600 or something, the answer can't be "All ~300+ of the students with unknown Class designations." Not unless... There hasn't been a massive influx of freshman students in 2006-2007, right? Just a massive influx of changelings, IIRC.
- Phoenix Spiritus
-

- Malady
-
Phoenix Spiritus wrote: Always remember, Gen 2 was setup with meticulous records and strict management of students and characters because, well, Gen 1 wasn't.
Yes. Thanks for bringing that up, for those who are reading in the future.
In this case, the Wiki is sort of being those meticulous records for Gen1. ... There was that project to generate a spreadsheet for Gen1, using the Gen2 sheet provided by ElrodW, as a basis... Given what I'm doing with the Wiki, noting those who have unknown powers, mainly, any such sheet should be easier to make?
- Phoenix Spiritus
-
Malady wrote:
Phoenix Spiritus wrote: Always remember, Gen 2 was setup with meticulous records and strict management of students and characters because, well, Gen 1 wasn't.
Yes. Thanks for bringing that up, for those who are reading in the future.
In this case, the Wiki is sort of being those meticulous records for Gen1. ... There was that project to generate a spreadsheet for Gen1, using the Gen2 sheet provided by ElrodW, as a basis... Given what I'm doing with the Wiki, noting those who have unknown powers, mainly, any such sheet should be easier to make?
And I can assure you, the current authors are very appreciative and refer to the Wiki compulsively.
I was more warning you to not expect strict attention to the "rules and guidelines" for Gen 1 students. Without the help of the original story writers, it might prove near impossible to sort it all out "authoritatively".
- Malady
-
Phoenix Spiritus wrote:
Malady wrote:
Phoenix Spiritus wrote: Always remember, Gen 2 was setup with meticulous records and strict management of students and characters because, well, Gen 1 wasn't.
Yes. Thanks for bringing that up, for those who are reading in the future.
In this case, the Wiki is sort of being those meticulous records for Gen1. ... There was that project to generate a spreadsheet for Gen1, using the Gen2 sheet provided by ElrodW, as a basis... Given what I'm doing with the Wiki, noting those who have unknown powers, mainly, any such sheet should be easier to make?
And I can assure you, the current authors are very appreciative and refer to the Wiki compulsively.
I was more warning you to not expect strict attention to the "rules and guidelines" for Gen 1 students. Without the help of the original story writers, it might prove near impossible to sort it all out "authoritatively".
Well, a lot can be handwaved as "Unknown history", like a influx of 300+ froshes each year could be that every once in a while, there's a mass... Let's say culling, of the student population, and they need the space for the froshes, so that's why there's room for 600+ students, and why the upper years have drastically lower populations...
Also, mass skewing towards certain powers can be blamed on unknown bits of history, like a massive ESPer network across the world skewing to ESPers, or tech proliferation skewing to Gadgs, more Sci-Fi / Fantasy that doesn't fit Whateleyverse reality skewing to DEVs, etc. ... Pop culture boosting people's sense of self-worth or something, skewing to EX-es... Spirits being more common, making more AV-es... Etc.
***
Edit: But, back to the wiki. Do you guys have any categories that you want?
- Sir Lee
-
- As has been pointed out, not every student finishes Whateley. OTOH, non-freshman transfer are apparently rare -- the school has a tendency to push transfers to go back to Freshman if possible so they take the full four years. So, on attrition alone, one should expect the Senior class to be somewhat smaller than the Freshman class.
- Also, it is canon that the number of admissions is increasing at a rate fast enough to be noticeable even by Phase, who does not have full access to long-term student statistics. That also points to a larger Freshman.class.
Adding the two effects, I would guess that each new class is at maybe ten students larger than the previous one. That would mean that Class of 2007 was something like 135 students, while Class of 2010 is maybe 165.
- elrodw
-
We have a spreadsheet for our students, which has already proven worth its weight in gold to find 'unassigned' characters - and as we 'use' them, we fill in details. Not sure if we're going to present this to the wiki in toto or as the students are revealed. We haven't debated that. And as the students get revealed, we'll have to see how much of the character sheets we reveal (more detail, background, etc)
Never give up, Never surrender! Captain Peter Quincy Taggert
- Sir Lee
-
Malady wrote: Is redirecting things back to the page they link from, in any way a good idea, if they're only linked from one location, or something, like Catherine Cody and Mr. Cody, who are only linked from the Kodiak page?
Offhand, I would say... no, it's not a particularly good idea. Yes, it eliminates the ugly red link... but it doesn't give the visitor any new information, and, by hiding it from the "wanted pages" list, it decreases the chance that someone will bother to make an actual page.
Redirects are useful for a lot of things... but reflexive redirects aren't very helpful. They can also be confusing to the visitor: say you are in the Kodiak page, click on the blue link for Catherine Cody, and the Kodiak page reloads. The first reaction of the user is probably to wonder if whether the Wiki or his browser are broken.
Category pages and writeup pages fulfill two different purposes. Whoever clicks on the "were" link on Cyberkitty page is probably looking for info about what is a were within the Whateley framework. If they want to know "who else is a were", well, there's an explicit "Category:were" link at the bottom.Malady wrote: Also, should we link to Categories? 'Cause Cyberkitty wants Were and Cyberpath pages, but we have Were and Technopath Categories, with descriptions... But then again, Exemplar has both Category and Article versions... Perhaps make and redirect the pages into the categories for now?
Yes, we could in theory to put all the info in the Category page and use the regular page as a redirect... but that only makes sense for categories where we don't have much to say. But then we have categories like Wizard and Esper, where the descriptive page is very long... so, for the sake of consistency, we have heretofore kept the two things separate.
Having a lot of wanted pages is not bad in itself. The ones called from a single page don't worry me very much -- they are mostly for characters who have appeared only once, and there's not much to say about them. But if they appear again, well, they will be bumped up in the "wanted" list, and that will call attention to their possible relevance. Some of them are misspelled links, that can be solved by either editing the original page or adding a redirect, depending on the case.Malady wrote: Then again, we're at
900899 wanted pages. Leaving room for a few more wanted pages to stay, even as others are made...
We could make a concerted effort to reduce the number of wanted pages linked from several pages, however. Now and then I tackle a few of them... but it has been a while since my last wiki-clearing marathon, I admit.
- Valentine
-
The notes are not super informative, but generally help find them or why they are listed.
There are 657 students alive and enrolled at some point during the Spring Semester, another 9 that died/were expelled/banished to another plane/graduated early. Three changed names, one of which is thought to have died (Folder).
Now some of these names have Codenames but no known realname, and vice-versa. 214 students with a Codename, but no real name. And less than 100 with a real name and no known Codename.
Another 6 that either died or otherwise left school that may have been students in 2006/7. And one that committed suicide 4 to 6 years earlier.
Don't Drick and Drive.
- Malady
-
Valentine wrote: I have a spreadsheet for the 2006-07 that has a list of all the students, by Codename, realname, Cottage, Class, and a little note about them.
The notes are not super informative, but generally help find them or why they are listed.
That's nice to know.
Valentine wrote: Now some of these names have Codenames but no known realname, and vice-versa. 214 students with a Codename, but no real name. And less than 100 with a real name and no known Codename.
Well, the latter are easily detectable, 'cause they aren't listed by codename. For the former, could you add the missing ones to the Unknown_Real_Name Category? I've got 91 of them, but right now, atm, I'm trying to pin down the non-Seniors by going through the Insanity Prereq WhatLinksHere for students that went to the dance and therefore aren't seniors. Already went through Devil's Dance.
Why are the non-dancers Seniors? I guess they were gathered to discuss the Legacy and trapped? (Edit: Nope. There's a Senior’s Bash. That's why they're not at the dance and participating in the action. Edit2: And the Bash has been mentioned nowhere in the Wiki... Where should I mention it??) ... Is there a Dark Legacy every year? If so, what's 2006-2007's?
- Valentine
-
Malady wrote:
Valentine wrote: I have a spreadsheet for the 2006-07 that has a list of all the students, by Codename, realname, Cottage, Class, and a little note about them.
The notes are not super informative, but generally help find them or why they are listed.
That's nice to know.
Valentine wrote: Now some of these names have Codenames but no known realname, and vice-versa. 214 students with a Codename, but no real name. And less than 100 with a real name and no known Codename.
Well, the latter are easily detectable, 'cause they aren't listed by codename. For the former, could you add the missing ones to the Unknown_Real_Name Category? I've got 91 of them, but right now, atm, I'm trying to pin down the non-Seniors by going through the Insanity Prereq WhatLinksHere for students that went to the dance and therefore aren't seniors. Already went through Devil's Dance.
Why are the non-dancers Seniors? I guess they were gathered to discuss the Legacy and trapped? (Edit: Nope. There's a Senior’s Bash. That's why they're not at the dance and participating in the action. Edit2: And the Bash has been mentioned nowhere in the Wiki... Where should I mention it??) ... Is there a Dark Legacy every year? If so, what's 2006-2007's?
Edit3: And there's only 9 students I can confirm as not-seniors with that method...Not done...
Not everyone that wasn't a Senior went to the Dance. The Bad Seeds, except for Thrasher, didn't go, Gemonacer didn't go. It's also possible that a Senior went because they liked that party better.
Don't Drick and Drive.
- Malady
-
Valentine wrote: Not everyone that wasn't a Senior went to the Dance. The Bad Seeds, except for Thrasher, didn't go, Gemonacer didn't go. It's also possible that a Senior went because they liked that party better.
... Well, shoot. Gonna focus on the those without Real Names, then... That shouldn't have any false conclusions... ... Or go back to making dates and months.
Edit: ... What to do with those with 2005 Canon Bible info, that isn't stated anywhere else, like Akira's real name of Micheal Parsons? I'll just leave those people alone...
Canon Cabalists, any categories you want to request?
- mittfh
-
Topic Author
elrodw wrote: INot sure if we're going to present this to the wiki in toto or as the students are revealed.
Given that with the exception of background material revealed in forums, the Wiki has always been no more up to date than revealed canon (and for obvious reasons, usually lags behind!), I'd say add / edit characters only once they've shown up in canon (and probably had more exposure than a five second cameo).
As the right side of the brain controls the left side of the body, then only left-handers are in their right mind!
- Malady
-
I've been thinking, how about sorting the students whose cottages we don't know, into girls and boys or something, so we can pin them down that little bit more?
The category names would get a bit long, perhaps... Maybe "Male Student", "Female Student", "Unknown Gender Student", and have the general Student category just encompass those three? ... Would sorting by sexes instead of gender be in any way more useful?
Well, until I get a response, I"m gonna be making dates and stuff?
***
@Valentine - Perhaps posting your spreadsheet, or sending it to me or someone to host, might be useful? ... Or not, if there's no sorting method that's not already been applied?
- Valentine
-
Malady wrote: Well, now I've gone through all the students and catalogued them by how much and how many of their names we know.
I've been thinking, how about sorting the students whose cottages we don't know, into girls and boys or something, so we can pin them down that little bit more?
The category names would get a bit long, perhaps... Maybe "Male Student", "Female Student", "Unknown Gender Student", and have the general Student category just encompass those three? ... Would sorting by sexes instead of gender be in any way more useful?
Well, until I get a response, I"m gonna be making dates and stuff?
***
@Valentine - Perhaps posting your spreadsheet, or sending it to me or someone to host, might be useful? ... Or not, if there's no sorting method that's not already been applied?
The problem with sorting students by sex/gender is that you don't have the Male/Female/Unknown. You also have Vamp, Phase, Reach, Chimera(?), Jimmy T., Generator, Mega-Girl, and others. (OK Generator and Mega-Girl are girls, or at least on their way to being girls.)
I don't have a place to put it up, but I can email you a copy. PM me your email, and I will send it off.
Don't Drick and Drive.
- Malady
-
Valentine wrote:
Malady wrote: Well, now I've gone through all the students and catalogued them by how much and how many of their names we know.
I've been thinking, how about sorting the students whose cottages we don't know, into girls and boys or something, so we can pin them down that little bit more?
The category names would get a bit long, perhaps... Maybe "Male Student", "Female Student", "Unknown Gender Student", and have the general Student category just encompass those three? ... Would sorting by sexes instead of gender be in any way more useful
The problem with sorting students by sex/gender is that you don't have the Male/Female/Unknown. You also have Vamp, Phase, Reach, Chimera(?), Jimmy T., Generator, Mega-Girl, and others. (OK Generator and Mega-Girl are girls, or at least on their way to being girls.)
Well, the point is to say that "We might not know what cottage this student is in, but as they are ________ we can say that they're (not) in Whitman and Dickinson / Twain and Emerson"
I guess "Not Whitman or Dickinson Cottage" and "Not Twain or Emerson Cottage" are short enough to use? ... And most of the Cottage Unknowns are easily confirmed as not in Hawthorne or Poe...
So, "Whitman or Dickinson Cottage" and "Twain or Emerson Cottage" might be good categories...
No, then it's sort of useless it's just saying guy/girl, which is either unknown, or easily determined from the name...
- elrodw
-
In Gen 2, we use the following:Malady wrote:
Valentine wrote: The problem with sorting students by sex/gender is that you don't have the Male/Female/Unknown. You also have Vamp, Phase, Reach, Chimera(?), Jimmy T., Generator, Mega-Girl, and others. (OK Generator and Mega-Girl are girls, or at least on their way to being girls.)
Well, the point is to say that "We might not know what cottage this student is in, but as they are ________ we can say that they're (not) in Whitman and Dickinson / Twain and Emerson"
I guess "Not Whitman or Dickinson Cottage" and "Not Twain or Emerson Cottage" are short enough to use? ... And most of the Cottage Unknowns are easily confirmed as not in Hawthorne or Poe...
So, "Whitman or Dickinson Cottage" and "Twain or Emerson Cottage" might be good categories...
No, then it's sort of useless it's just saying guy/girl, which is either unknown, or easily determined from the name...
M, F, MtF, FtM, C (for complex, e.g. shifter, hermaphrodite, etc)
That type of scheme might help
Never give up, Never surrender! Captain Peter Quincy Taggert
- Malady
-
elrodw wrote:
In Gen 2, we use the following:Malady wrote:
Valentine wrote: The problem with sorting students by sex/gender is that you don't have the Male/Female/Unknown. You also have Vamp, Phase, Reach, Chimera(?), Jimmy T., Generator, Mega-Girl, and others. (OK Generator and Mega-Girl are girls, or at least on their way to being girls.)
Well, the point is to say that "We might not know what cottage this student is in, but as they are ________ we can say that they're (not) in Whitman and Dickinson / Twain and Emerson"
I guess "Not Whitman or Dickinson Cottage" and "Not Twain or Emerson Cottage" are short enough to use? ... And most of the Cottage Unknowns are easily confirmed as not in Hawthorne or Poe...
So, "Whitman or Dickinson Cottage" and "Twain or Emerson Cottage" might be good categories...
No, then it's sort of useless it's just saying guy/girl, which is either unknown, or easily determined from the name...
M, F, MtF, FtM, C (for complex, e.g. shifter, hermaphrodite, etc)
That type of scheme might help
Hmm... It would... Maybe... It's not a perfect solution for the "Determining what cottage are they in to the best of our ability" sort-of-problem, but a partial solution is better than none? ... It would be a perfect solution / replacement If all the MtFs and FtMs and Cs were in Poe, then it would be the same as sorting by cottage... But it's not, and I have to live with that.
- NeoMagus
-
elrodw wrote: In Gen 2, we use the following:
M, F, MtF, FtM, C (for complex, e.g. shifter, hermaphrodite, etc)
That type of scheme might help
Pretty sure "C" was originally intended to mean "complicated" rather than complex, but either way works.
... . . -.- / .--- ..- ... - .. -.-. . .-.-.- / .-.. --- ...- . / -- . .-. -.-. -.-- .-.-.- / .-- .- .-.. -.- / .... ..- -- -... .-.. -.-- / .-- .. - .... / -.-- --- ..- .-. / --. --- -.. .-.-.-
- Arcanist Lupus
-
I'm sure that there are many students with an imaginary component to their gender.NeoMagus wrote:
elrodw wrote: In Gen 2, we use the following:
M, F, MtF, FtM, C (for complex, e.g. shifter, hermaphrodite, etc)
That type of scheme might help
Pretty sure "C" was originally intended to mean "complicated" rather than complex, but either way works.

"Shared pain is lessened; shared joy, increased — thus do we refute entropy." - Spider Robinson
- Valentine
-
Arcanist Lupus wrote:
I'm sure that there are many students with an imaginary component to their gender.NeoMagus wrote:
elrodw wrote: In Gen 2, we use the following:
M, F, MtF, FtM, C (for complex, e.g. shifter, hermaphrodite, etc)
That type of scheme might help
Pretty sure "C" was originally intended to mean "complicated" rather than complex, but either way works.
Those students list their gender as "i"
Don't Drick and Drive.
- Malady
-
Edit: That's weird... It opens when Outlook or Google does it, but not on my home comp's Excel...
Theophany, "Needs to be rebuilt and girlified" ? ... Ah. Adding more info to his/her wiki page then. I suppose he's transgendered as well...
Theo's part of Cocercivity... And the only known member... All those junior and higher, except for the Pacifists, have to be on a training team? IIRC? And there's the Administration-created teams, which are the Strike Teams? And the minimum number of members is 4? The maximum number is
crystalhall.wikia.com/wiki/List_of_Combat_(Training)_Teams
Edit2: Pining down who could be on Nations Combat Team 2. See the page.
***
Delete this typoed link?
- Sir Lee
-
Here's the thing: this IP has done a few anonymous edits to the Wiki in the past. They weren't vandalism, only... well, maybe poorly-formatted and in some cases arguable on merits, but not really wrong. For instance, last month they created a perfectly valid entry for Camille Anders -- I had to polish it up, but it was valid info for a real Whateley character, a protagonist even, who so far didn't have her own page. So I have been assuming that this is a Whateley fan who just haven't learned much about Wiki editing but wanted to help. And I'm OK with that -- polishing up a badly-formatted but otherwise valid article is way less work than it would be to create the article from scratch, so this contributor has been helping us.
But then today I came up with another new article... for a character which, to the best of my knowledge, has not been seen anywhere. I'm sorry, but I'm going to have to delete this. If it's a fanfic character, the wiki is not the place for them -- fanfic characters are only included in very special cases, when they are considered semi-canon or similar.
Now, it's possible that this anonymous contributor is a canon author and this is a soon-to-be-introduced character. If that's the case, we run into another problem... namely, spoilers. If you are a canon author and wish to help us in the wiki team with the entry for you character, just send the info in PM for one of the regular contributors you trust -- if they have the info in hand, they will upload it as soon as the story is posted -- but not before.
- DanZilla
-
And it wasn't written by a canon author nor, to my knowledge, is it under consideration for canon at this time.
- Kristin Darken
-
Sir Lee wrote: ...okay... does anybody know who is the user with IP 68.0.145.94? From what I could figure out, it's a cox.net subscriber somewhere around Tucson, Arizona.
When you were having problems with this person last time around, I did an IP check on registered users and didn't find the address associated with a registered account. Or even with a non-registered commenter on stories... kinda bizarre that they'll put in wiki info but won't commit to activity on the forums. *shrugs*
Fate guard you and grant you a Light to brighten your Way.
- Sir Lee
-
On updating the Nightfox entry, I noticed that she is listed both as "Expelled" and "Alumni." Now, I'm not sure on the nuances of the thing, but I thought that "alumni" generally referred to people who have actually graduated from a school. But the actual dictionary meaning is not the salient point here...
The point here is what's the best option from an organizing/searching standpoint.
- Should all "Expelled" be also listed as "Alumni?"
- Should they just be listed as "Expelled", but the category:Expelled be a subcategory of Alumni?
- Or should they be separate things?
- Malady
-
Mixing them together makes things really confusing. ... Is Nightfox the only one with both Expelled and Alumni? ... Checking...
***
JohnMead made the Expelled Page and currently all Expelled are in the Alumni Category. I vote to remove that... Among what I'd assume is all of the Expelled... Well, any alterations to the Alumni-Expelled Fusion-Whatever status are pending this vote...
Voting lasts for... how long? 1 day? 1 week? 2 weeks? 1 month?
***
And Mead also made Hekate an Alumni and Expelled. crystalhall.wikia.com/wiki/Hekate?diff=next&oldid=16347
On that note... Gonna leave a note for myself: "Remove Sidhe from Exemplar 'cause they're not really Exemplars... More like Psuedo-Exemplars, 'cause they're evolved, but no BIT? ... Vote on that after this... Maybe."
- DanZilla
-
If it helps here's a link to Acknowledged alumni from Harvard that didn't graduate...
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Harvard_Un..._non-graduate_alumni
- Kristin Darken
-
What you're looking for would be "Exemplar equivalent"Malady wrote: On that note... Gonna leave a note for myself: "Remove Sidhe from Exemplar 'cause they're not really Exemplars... More like Psuedo-Exemplars, 'cause they're evolved, but no BIT? ... Vote on that after this... Maybe."
Similar to how we describe the natural healing rates of a non-Regenerator Exemplar or Energizer - they have an ability to heal similar to that of a certain rank Regen, but it's purely a 'side effect' of specific processes that are part of another trait.
Fate guard you and grant you a Light to brighten your Way.
- Sir Lee
-
- DanZilla
-
Edit: yep... from Luna 1: Drafted
My guardian, a widow with two grown up children who lived in Boston and New York, was called Mrs Waterford, though she insisted I call her Agnes
- Sir Lee
-
- Malady
-
- Sir Lee
-
- Malady
-
Mainly 'cause I'm looking through the Orphaned Pages... And noticed some People that are Orphaned, liked Anne Clearlake .
But, they've got categories, and are searchable, so they can be found if needed.
... Are the Disappeared supposed to be Deceased? Like Roberta Jennings? Personally, I'd say that they're not Deceased until said in-story?
- Valentine
-
Malady wrote: Should we add people to the Indexes, even though they're apparently getting really big? 'Cause there are some people that aren't listed there, like most of the Gen2 set?
Gen 2 should get their own index of characters.
Malady wrote: Mainly 'cause I'm looking through the Orphaned Pages... And noticed some People that are Orphaned, liked Anne Clearlake .
But, they've got categories, and are searchable, so they can be found if needed.
Some of the characters are just mentioned in one story, So they will only be linked from a one or two other places.
Malady wrote: ... Are the Disappeared supposed to be Deceased? Like Roberta Jennings? Personally, I'd say that they're not Deceased until said in-story?
the Disappeared are the mutant kids that the MCO took custody of, and then disappeared denying that they ever took custody of them. Most of them are just mentioned one story some get mentioned more than once..
Don't Drick and Drive.
- mittfh
-
Topic Author
As the right side of the brain controls the left side of the body, then only left-handers are in their right mind!
- Domoviye
-
I think I did everything properly, including some links, but if someone with more experience could look it over for me, I'd appreciate it.
- Valentine
-
Domoviye wrote: I made a page for the side character Shisa.
I think I did everything properly, including some links, but if someone with more experience could look it over for me, I'd appreciate it.
The story references should be done like this.
<ref name = "story nick name">''[ [Story name#Part number|Story name: Part number] ]''</ref> and stuck at the the end of the reference.
Eliminate the space between the brackets [[ not [ [.
The quotes around the story nick name are double quotes, the other quotes are paired apostrophes (single quotes).
Don't Drick and Drive.
- Domoviye
-
- Valentine
-
Don't Drick and Drive.
- Malady
-
"Something something tell..." Nice Work!
And then I clicked it, and it turned into "Thank you for telling Domoviye Nice Work!"
... What did I just do???!???
***
@Domoviye - Note that internal links are done with [[ ]]. Fixed on the I_Don't_Think_We're_in_Kansas_Anymore page.
- Sir Lee
-
It's a Wikia/MediaWiki feature that frankly, I hadn't noticed before... and I think I'll start using now. So many times I review someone's editing and should have given them kudos and didn't...Malady wrote: ... Just looked at Domoviye's edit with the revision analysis feature and there was a thing that was
"Something something tell..." Nice Work!
And then I clicked it, and it turned into "Thank you for telling Domoviye Nice Work!"
... What did I just do???!???
- NeoMagus
-
... . . -.- / .--- ..- ... - .. -.-. . .-.-.- / .-.. --- ...- . / -- . .-. -.-. -.-- .-.-.- / .-- .- .-.. -.- / .... ..- -- -... .-.. -.-- / .-- .. - .... / -.-- --- ..- .-. / --. --- -.. .-.-.-
- Pempelune
-
- Sir Lee
-
- NeoMagus
-
Pempelune wrote: Uh, there is two characters with the same codename? Ugh, that's gonna cause some problems.
Two different generations, so the occasions where you might confuse the two should be few and far between.
Also, thanks, Sir Lee! I'd have tried to fix it myself, but I have absolutely no experience working with wikis, and I didn't want to mess anything up.
... . . -.- / .--- ..- ... - .. -.-. . .-.-.- / .-.. --- ...- . / -- . .-. -.-. -.-- .-.-.- / .-- .- .-.. -.- / .... ..- -- -... .-.. -.-- / .-- .. - .... / -.-- --- ..- .-. / --. --- -.. .-.-.-
- elrodw
-
Never give up, Never surrender! Captain Peter Quincy Taggert
- Valentine
-
Pempelune wrote: Uh, there is two characters with the same codename? Ugh, that's gonna cause some problems.
In Gen1 there are two Olympias and two Frostbites and two using Thorn all at Whateley at the same time.
Don't Drick and Drive.
- Sir Lee
-
- Kristin Darken
-
Fate guard you and grant you a Light to brighten your Way.
- Sir Lee
-
But it probably won't be a wholesale search-and-replace thing; We might have to create a page explaining the concept of WhatIF so we don't have to explain it all the time...
- Kristin Darken
-
Fate guard you and grant you a Light to brighten your Way.
- Valentine
-
Don't Drick and Drive.
- elrodw
-
Never give up, Never surrender! Captain Peter Quincy Taggert
- Sir Lee
-
- Sir Lee
-
Thing is, it is currently hosted in the "Library" section. Wouldn't it be more appropriate to move it to the "Featured WhatIF", now that we HAVE such a section?
- Kristin Darken
-
Fate guard you and grant you a Light to brighten your Way.
- mittfh
-
Topic Author
elrodw wrote: Just wondering - is there a goal to get all the story summaries or synopses or writeups up to date and consistent?
Getting the story Lists up to date might be a useful start... now I wonder who's responsible for those... oh, me...
I've had a busy few weeks, so hopefully over the next few days I'll get that end of things at least up to date.
Although of course, as Wikis are designed to be collaborative projects, it doesn't preclude anyone from updating the Lists themselves (as opposed to just fixing foul-ups) - I don't claim ownership over them (despite being the primary maintainer) and on one of the page's Talk links have even included the Javascript code responsible for the word counts.
As the right side of the brain controls the left side of the body, then only left-handers are in their right mind!
- Sir Lee
-
- Phoenix Spiritus
-
- Valentine
-
Don't Drick and Drive.
- Sir Lee
-
- Cryptic
-
I am a caffeine heathen; I prefer the waters of the mountain over the juice of the bean. Keep the Dews coming and no one will be hurt.
- Sir Lee
-
Personally, I would include that info in a small descriptive paragraph for each monster category, between the subheading and the list of transformees. That could include a short description of the nature of the transformation, too.
- Cryptic
-
I am a caffeine heathen; I prefer the waters of the mountain over the juice of the bean. Keep the Dews coming and no one will be hurt.
- Malady
-
- Cryptic
-
I am a caffeine heathen; I prefer the waters of the mountain over the juice of the bean. Keep the Dews coming and no one will be hurt.
- Cryptic
-
I am a caffeine heathen; I prefer the waters of the mountain over the juice of the bean. Keep the Dews coming and no one will be hurt.
- Malady
-
Cryptic wrote: I have a Cyber-tribe entry written up, I just don't remember how to add a new page.
crystalhall.wikia.com/wiki/Special:CreatePage
- Cryptic
-
I am a caffeine heathen; I prefer the waters of the mountain over the juice of the bean. Keep the Dews coming and no one will be hurt.
- mittfh
-
Topic Author
...although, of course, as the Wiki is an open platform, anyone who can figure out how Wiki tables work is free to update the pages themselves (hint, hint!)...
As the right side of the brain controls the left side of the body, then only left-handers are in their right mind!
- Malady
-
Yeah. Maybe I'll go update the list... Maybe.
- jmhyp
-
Speaking of the wiki, why isn't there a link to it in, say, offsite links?
- Valentine
-
jmhyp wrote: The entry for Knockoff needs updating. It states that Knockoff's transgender status was left off her application to Whateley but There's no Place Like Poe shows she ended up in Poe. So something's isn't correct there.
Speaking of the wiki, why isn't there a link to it in, say, offsite links?
While her journey to Whateley hasn't been told. She did leave her TG status off her application.
The WIKI link is under WA Universe.
Don't Drick and Drive.
- elrodw
-
Or Wildhammer simply reported it during a staff meeting at Whateley before the students arrived, which resulted in her being placed in Poe .....Valentine wrote:
jmhyp wrote: The entry for Knockoff needs updating. It states that Knockoff's transgender status was left off her application to Whateley but There's no Place Like Poe shows she ended up in Poe. So something's isn't correct there.
Speaking of the wiki, why isn't there a link to it in, say, offsite links?
While her journey to Whateley hasn't been told. She did leave her TG status off her application.
possible story happenings [ Click to expand ] [ Click to hide ]Likely Wildhammer, who knew about the status, either saw the application, or otherwise found out and talked to her and got her to admit to her status and was placed in Poe.
The WIKI link is under WA Universe.
Never give up, Never surrender! Captain Peter Quincy Taggert
- Cryptic
-
I am a caffeine heathen; I prefer the waters of the mountain over the juice of the bean. Keep the Dews coming and no one will be hurt.
- elrodw
-
transgendered (not a word) to transgender. Not sure why I am bothering. Even the category is named "transgendered" characters. It is a little too obvious that few if any actual transgender people are involved in this wiki.
fixed offensive shit. transgendered (not a word) to transgender
transgendered (not a word) to transgender. FYI, she-male is just as offensive as tranny. Don't use it
transgendered (not a word) to transgender. The entire category should be deleted and be replaced with "transgender students". Type the non-word "transgendered" into google and you can find a number of explanations.
transgendered (not a word) to transgender. sex to gender. sigh
she-male is a disgusting, objectifying porn term. Describing a character that way is more than a little offensive to anyone who is trans (like I am)
Never give up, Never surrender! Captain Peter Quincy Taggert
- Sir Lee
-
There's a difference between complaining about incorrect terminology and complaining about disliked terminology, however; in the first case, there is a general consensus on what the correct form is, and in the second case this consensus has not been reached yet, no matter how good are the arguments of the people defending a particular position.
So it falls upon us, as editors, to determine:
(a) if a term is indeed incorrect, and if so, to correct it.
(b) if a term, while technically not incorrect, is appropriate to the entry, and if not, to choose a more appropriate term. Note that appropriate does not necessarily means non-offensive; it means that it fits the tone and message of the passage and/or the full entry.
- Kristin Darken
-
In this case, we have two fairly justifiable reasons for using the 'wrong' words... the first one is that the current 'correct' language for a LOT of gender studies and human sexuality terms are very new. Like, last five years news. If you haven't taken a gender studies course in the last five years, some kid feeling their freak pride at college could be calling you out on using the 'wrong words' for something you have been writing about for multiple decades. The second is... what language offends me isn't always what offends others. To me, being a 'freak' is something offensive/insulting... but is actually mainstream enough that its the basis for a song in the Shrek Musical and applies to all sorts of differences... and something to be 'proud' of.
Transgender vs transgendered - yes, truthfully, the former is preferred over the latter. Mainly because this implies a state of existence (its an adjective) as opposed to a condition or something imposed on someone (an action/verb). Ironically, in the WU, there are probably more instances of where the state WAS imposed on someone instead of it being their natural state of being. Either word is correct, if used in the appropriate grammatical position (ie transgender as an adjective, transgendered as the past tense of a weak verb).
As to the rest? If this individual would like to pop in and chat about why specific words would be preferred... I'm willing to hear them out. But as someone who has been reading and writing TG Fiction for more than two decades (for longer than the WWW has been around to host it - yes, there were TG Fiction BBS's back in the early 90's),.. I'm not especially moved by the argument "you must not be TG because if you were, you'd be just as offended by this as I am." I'm far more offended by someone who insults the volunteer work of others without the courtesy of actively participating / contributing to that community.
Fate guard you and grant you a Light to brighten your Way.
- elrodw
-
The English language is not a static thing, but changes continually. Words that once meant something - especially in common street usage - now are archaic or mean something different. We still read "Huckleberry Finn" (at least those of us who aren't snowflakes with hair-triggers) even though it uses a particularly offensive word to refer to melanin-gifted individuals. At the time the story was written, it was in common use and we understand that. The word "audition" used to mean the power of hearing, but now means a try-out for something. Seldom does a person use "breech" to describe a person's buttocks, and one does not describe kids "disporting" about, but instead uses "frolicking"
It would be an impossible - and quite unfortunate - task if the old words were periodically purged and updated. Much of the etymological evolution of our language would be lost if out-of-date or newly-offensive words were purged. At the time the wiki entries were written, the terms were used, and in some cases, taken directly from stories. Do they offend people now? Probably there are some extra-touchy persons who take offense where none was intended.
Please get a wiki account if you want to edit things, and if you have points about language, by all means start a discussion here on the forums - civil, of course, or one of us WILL moderate any hostility out. We listen - probably more than you suspect, and a well-reasoned discussion will do more to educate people than you think.
Please do NOT expect us to go back and update the verbage in our older stories. But if change is warranted and rationally argued, then I can tell you that I will change appropriately. However, if you try to bludgeon me or any author into accepting your word without said calm, rational discussion, don't be surprised if you encounter more than a trifling amount of stubornness.
Never give up, Never surrender! Captain Peter Quincy Taggert
- Malady
-
I saw those edits in my notifications, and didn't revert 'cause they felt minor, and sorta nitpicky to me?? ... When they did "she-male", if that was the
... Is she-male used in-story for anyone other than Ayla? ... Yes. it is, for Gracie, as her own words: Ayla 1 :
"He looked at me in the rearview mirror and sighed, “No, I don’t want to get my dick cut off, and I don’t want to date guys. I just want to be me. And this is me. I’m what is called a she-male.”"
So, we have a leg to stand on, if anyone feels like using it.
- Sir Lee
-
Ayla also uses the "she-male" term at times, for different reasons than Gracie's -- Ayla does not see himself as trans in any way (rather, he sees himself as a genetic, heterosexual, cisgender male with an unfortunate acquired deformity), so he rejects the transgender labels.
However, the character's chosen term is not necessarily the best descriptive term to be used in a Wiki entry, where the POV is supposed to be more or less neutral and detached. Thus we include Ayla in the "transgendered characters" category despite his rejection of the term -- it is not his self-identity, but by circumstance he finds himself placed as part of the group.
Consider the so-called "n-word." There are plenty of people who self-describe as such, but it would still be inappropriate for, say, Wikipedia or mainstream press to use the n-word to characterize them, other than in direct quotes.
Now, most of those can be evaluated on a case-by-case basis, except for the category. While in real-world terms "transgender" is preferred to "transgendered" for the reasons mentioned by Diane, in WU terms this is not as clear; while we do have a number of true transgender characters (Jade, Toni, Gracie...), in that this is who they ARE as opposed as "something that was done to them", in the WU we have at least as many who can claim that "yes, this is something that was DONE to me, not who I am." Chou, Fey, Kayda, Folder to name a few. So for the category name, a consensus would be desirable.
With the 'bot, renaming a category is not too much work, so if consensus is that it should be renamed, I can do it. But perhaps an usage note explaining the choice of "transgendered" instead of "transgender" in the category page would be enough, or even better?
- Valentine
-
Ayla 1 wrote: Amy smiled, “I got a much better job. I wait tables at The Cherry Bomb, this strip club in The Square. All the waitresses and strippers are she-males or pre-op transsexuals. You have to have a dick to get a job there. The outfit is pretty sleazy. But the tips are great! I’m saving up for a new car - well, a new used car - and then I’m going to start saving up for breast implants. Dino, he’s the manager there, said if I got a set of D’s or bigger, I could start working as one of the strippers and make some real money.”
Ayla 1 wrote: Candace said, “I have no way to tell right now, but based on how your privates are behaving while the rest of your body seems to be feminizing, you may stay a she-male, like Gracie. Maybe we’ll know more after we get the test results back.”
So Ayla, Gracie, Amy, and Dr Candace Parsons all use the term verbally. Ayla also reports that Dr. Hammond uses it.
Don't Drick and Drive.
- Valentine
-
Malady wrote: Well, if Gracie is a she-male, she's not pre-op, then, 'cause she doesn't want the op at all and said "No, I don't want to get my dick cut off"?
'Cause the wiki says "She is a pre-op transsexual"...
That is the result of the anonymous editor. Which makes me think that he hasn't read the stories, but was just pointed this way.
Don't Drick and Drive.
- null0trooper
-
Sir Lee wrote: Yes, Gracie self-describes as a "she-male," while other people might variously describe her as a "pre-op/no-op transwoman." But it's her choice, it's how she defines herself.
Leaving aside the Western fascination with breasts, surgery doesn't ncessarily define a person's identity. Confirm ... maybe. YMWV. For third-party categorization, and the sanity of the Wiki maintainers, maybe we're all better off leaving "pre-op/no-op/post-op" out altogether?
If a character in the future is shown transitioning surgically over the course of their story, then transgendered back by their mutation, would it be all that useful for them to be listed all three ways?
Sir Lee wrote: Ayla also uses the "she-male" term at times, for different reasons than Gracie's -- Ayla does not see himself as trans in any way (rather, he sees himself as a genetic, heterosexual, cisgender male with an unfortunate acquired deformity), so he rejects the transgender labels.
If I recall correctly, he does (openly and repeatedly) recognize that he is physically intersexed.
Considering that Diamondback and Chimera have been written as bigender, that Gotterdammerung cross-dresses for psychological comfort, and that it does no one much good to break everything down to categories of one member each, I'm tempted to recommend a category of "Gender - It's Complicated. No. Really."
Sir Lee wrote: But perhaps an usage note explaining the choice of "transgendered" instead of "transgender" in the category page would be enough, or even better?
I think that that may be helpful, as the difference is a driving force in several stories.
Forum-posted ideas are freely adoptable.
WhatIF Stories: Buy the Book
Discussion Thread
- Schol-R-LEA
-
I was not aware of the differing opinions on the validity of 'transgender' versus 'transgendered', and if anything, everything I'd ever heard had always said the opposite - that 'transgender' implies that it is a thing one is, that is, an identity rather than a description (which is a big no-no in some circles), while 'transgendered' would be the preferred term because is it passive and descriptive. There seems to have been some change in views on this, and possibly some difference in views among different groups - and to be honest, I have never exactly been one to carefully observe the forefront of mainstream LGBTI thought, even when I was living in Berkeley and taking a more active role in the community.
I wouldn't ask people to change the stories, and I wouldn't go out of my way to change the wiki since it is a reflection of those stories despite being uncomfortable with a specific term in them. However, the only part of this that bothers me is that someone who doesn't seem to know the stories is poking into the wiki like that, especially if it is out of a desire to find something to be offended by.
Out, damnéd Spot! Bad Doggy!
- Malady
-
I was planning to fix the Grace Goodkind page by changing the "pre-op" bit to:
She is a she-male by choice, that is, willingly possessing a female body shape while retaining their male parts, having used a black-market devisor drug ...
But, does anyone have a good alternate for "she-male"? Otherwise, I'm voting to use it, as a phrase that's short and easy to type, and have the definition be a footnote, like how Goodkind family does it, with:
<ref name="Ayla1" /><ref name="she-male">''The term that's used in the stories is she-male. Please don't try to edit this to be politically correct again''</ref>
...
A Find for "She-male" in Ayla1 gets 20 hits.
Amy smiled, “I got a much better job. I wait tables at The Cherry Bomb, this strip club in The Square. All the waitresses and strippers are she-males or pre-op transsexuals.
- null0trooper
-
Malady wrote: But, does anyone have a good alternate for "she-male"?
"Genderqueer"? It even fits into the timeframe (I recall coming across the term in the 1990s.)
Forum-posted ideas are freely adoptable.
WhatIF Stories: Buy the Book
Discussion Thread
- Schol-R-LEA
-
Mind you, I am fairly certain that A Fandom User (which is the name automatically assigned to any anonymous contributor on Wikia) has no real familiarity with the series, and I suspect that if they did, they would be here complaining about how offensive the premise of the series is to them, instead. I may be wrong about this, so I wouldn't want to assume so, however.
My suspicion is that they were doing a general search on the term 'transgender' on Wikia (or even just through a general search engine) for reasons unrelated to the series or the terminology, and on finding what they considered an incorrect usage, tried to politely correct it, and then, deciding to see where else this 'mistake' was made, stumbled across terms they found deeply hurtful - without knowing or caring about the context - and immediately took offense without looking any further.
I don't want to sound either defensive about the series, or dismissive of their hurt feelings, but I do think that this sort of thing does indicate a rush to judgment on their part. Whether they would see it less harshly if they knew the series, or more, I cannot say.
Out, damnéd Spot! Bad Doggy!
- elrodw
-
M - male
F - female
MtF - male to female (transgender)
FtM - female to male (transgender)
C - complex (could cover the bases discussed above)
I also have Orientation:
Gay
Het
Bi
Complex
Asexual
So that really SHOULD cover things unless someone gets triggered by the terms I'm now using, and which are baselined in our character spreadsheets.
Never give up, Never surrender! Captain Peter Quincy Taggert
- Schol-R-LEA
-
@BabyValentine: The problem is, even in the series it's an offensive term to most trans* people. Grace uses it, for whatever in-character reasons of her own, and Trevor/Ayla used it because he didn't know the formal terms and, given his state of mind initially, probably would have chosen the slur anyway; but that's all about the in-character explanations, which don't explain why the authors wrote it that way.
I suspect the real answer lies in the fact that ScramblerJ - who vanished from the group shortly after writing their part of the intro - thought it was the correct term, and no one in the Canon Cabal seems to have corrected that or objected to it. Why this would be the case I can't say, but... well, AFAICT, while several of the original cabal (most notably Bek) had been writing sex/gender transformation fiction for years at that point, I don't think any of them knew any real-life transfolk very well. They were in the same boat as ScramblerJ.
I don't know how Diane is about this, but she's savvy enough that I am guessing she did know it was a slur, but as with many other aspects of Ayla's back story, she had been backed into a corner with the existing intro dialogue, so she wrote it in a way as to explain why an otherwise intelligent person was talking this way. A lot of Ayla's original persona got retconned by Diane as otherwise out-of-character reactions to his recent experiences (or, as in the case of people using female pronouns for a female-appearing but male-identifying character, being the perceptions of others rather than Ayla's own internal viewpoint), and I have always chalked this up to the same thing.
To the anonymous editor: As I said, most of the writers in this group aren't trans* themselves (Dr. Bender is the exception to that, but she only transitioned recently, many years later), and AFAIK none were identifying as such at the time the series began. I am guessing the original members either didn't know it was a slur, or didn't want to step on the other writers' toes by calling them on it.
For myself, my gender is "dunno". While I do present as kinda sorta male in public, that's 10% cowardice and 90% inertia; as for my preferred presentation, you're reading it - if it were feasible, I would avoid all face-to-face contact with other H. saps entirely.
Out, damnéd Spot! Bad Doggy!
- Kristin Darken
-
Schol-R-LEA wrote: As I said, most of the writers in this group aren't trans* themselves (Dr. Bender is the exception to that, but she only transitioned recently, many years later), and AFAIK none were identifying as such at the time the series began. I am guessing the original members either didn't know it was a slur, or didn't want to step on the other writers' toes by calling them on it.
This is actually quite far from the truth and completely misses the point of the stories originally starting development and release almost 15 years ago. It might not seem like a big deal to talk about transitioning and being pre-op vs post and so on in a discussion about gender and sexuality today... but 15 years ago? 20? Seriously... the stories of that time frame are some of the origin points of the words now used freely by the LGBT movement. Back then, people were still writing stories about how taking an accidental dose of hormones from birth control pills or drinking some of your aunt's lactation tea would suddenly transform a poor unfortunate boy into a curvy stripper girl. The 'politically correct' language insisted on today didn't exist yet. It COULDN'T exist yet, because you not only couldn't use the 'wrong' words and offend someone... you couldn't use ANY words to talk about the subject without getting mockery, disowned, fired, and so on.
Most of the cabal authors? Not TG? Ha. Most of the cabal authors were not TRANSITIONING... but that means nothing. Most of the cabal authors were not young. Nor have we magickally gotten younger since the creation of the universe. We mostly have/had lives and jobs and commitments that were at risk even exploring the idea of writing TG Fiction... let alone going further and pursuing what we wished could be. Mostly, we have struggled with our inner demons through the medium of these written words... for some, it was enough... or some other outside element prevents active transition. For others, transition happened. But consider, in addition to the characters people created specifically for the main stories... we all included bits of ourselves via 'avatar' characters. How many of those have the gender of their author at birth?
Fate guard you and grant you a Light to brighten your Way.
- Schol-R-LEA
-
Out, damnéd Spot! Bad Doggy!
- Schol-R-LEA
-
---
Anlage
Anlage is the black market devisor drug used by Grace Goodkind when she transitioned. Anlage causes the development of female secondary sexual characteristics, but does not alter the genitalia. [...]
---
Grace Goodkind
[...] She is transgender and physically intersexed, having used a black-market devisor drug called Anlage to alter her secondary sexual characteristics, and presents as female; she self-identifies as 'she-male' in the stories.
Out, damnéd Spot! Bad Doggy!
- Sir Lee
-
- Sir Lee
-
- Valentine
-
Schol-R-LEA wrote: This is a comment I added to the Discussion page for the Tiffany character entry . Note that I am trying to make peace here, not stir up more trouble; please take it in the spirit intended, and correct me if there is anything I have misunderstood.
@BabyValentine: The problem is, even in the series it's an offensive term to most trans* people. Grace uses it, for whatever in-character reasons of her own, and Trevor/Ayla used it because he didn't know the formal terms and, given his state of mind initially, probably would have chosen the slur anyway; but that's all about the in-character explanations, which don't explain why the authors wrote it that way.
I suspect the real answer lies in the fact that ScramblerJ - who vanished from the group shortly after writing their part of the intro - thought it was the correct term, and no one in the Canon Cabal seems to have corrected that or objected to it. Why this would be the case I can't say, but... well, AFAICT, while several of the original cabal (most notably Bek) had been writing sex/gender transformation fiction for years at that point, I don't think any of them knew any real-life transfolk very well. They were in the same boat as ScramblerJ.
I don't know how Diane is about this, but she's savvy enough that I am guessing she did know it was a slur, but as with many other aspects of Ayla's back story, she had been backed into a corner with the existing intro dialogue, so she wrote it in a way as to explain why an otherwise intelligent person was talking this way. A lot of Ayla's original persona got retconned by Diane as otherwise out-of-character reactions to his recent experiences (or, as in the case of people using female pronouns for a female-appearing but male-identifying character, being the perceptions of others rather than Ayla's own internal viewpoint), and I have always chalked this up to the same thing.
To the anonymous editor: As I said, most of the writers in this group aren't trans* themselves (Dr. Bender is the exception to that, but she only transitioned recently, many years later), and AFAIK none were identifying as such at the time the series began. I am guessing the original members either didn't know it was a slur, or didn't want to step on the other writers' toes by calling them on it.
For myself, my gender is "dunno". While I do present as kinda sorta male in public, that's 10% cowardice and 90% inertia; as for my preferred presentation, you're reading it - if it were feasible, I would avoid all face-to-face contact with other H. saps entirely.
Go back and reread Ayla and the Late Trevor Goodkind. Both terms, she-male and transgender or transsexual are used. They were used many times and often in the same sentence.
Trevor's thoughts during the drive to The Square: Which probably meant that a lot of those ‘hot babes’ were she-males or transsexuals too.
So he obviously knows the two words and they have different meanings.
Amy smiled, “I got a much better job. I wait tables at The Cherry Bomb, this strip club in The Square. All the waitresses and strippers are she-males or pre-op transsexuals. You have to have a dick to get a job there.
Here's Amy using both terms and again they are used to mean different people.
They are using the term to describe someone that wants a female body shape, while retaining their male parts. As opposed to a MtF transexual that wants to fully transition, whether or not they can afford it. (At least this is my interpretation of it.)
He looked at me in the rearview mirror and sighed, “No, I don’t want to get my dick cut off, and I don’t want to date guys. I just want to be me. And this is me. I’m what is called a she-male.”
Don't Drick and Drive.
- Sir Lee
-
- Malady
-
And they're moving FAST...
- Sir Lee
-
I hate to have to break out the LART, but changing categories wholesale, unilaterally, anonymously, without debate is a no-no -- it messes up the wiki's structure. It may be that in a few days I'll fire up the 'bot and do the exact same edits myself, but that is going to be after we reach a consensus on the best way to go forward.
- Schol-R-LEA
-
All it would have taken is for one 4chan prankster to notice it and call in a raid (which they might well do just 4 teh lulz) or one persistent asshole to decide we needed to be stopped at all costs, and it would be the 2015 crash all over again.
Wikia sites aren't quite so vulnerable, but this is one move I would have thought would be obvious from the start. Surely anyone who is actually a fan of the series would take the time to register and sign in if it was required, while a drive-by troll might decide it isn't worth their trouble. It's not a lot of protection, but surely it wouldn't be a major step to take.
Out, damnéd Spot! Bad Doggy!
- Sir Lee
-
"The majority of pages on a wiki should remain unprotected to encourage all users in the community to edit. It is against Fandom's Terms of Use to permanently protect large numbers of content pages. "
Fortunately, we have had very little problem with vandalism. I think this is only the fourth or fifth time I had to block an user.
But I guess I should step up the frequency of wiki backups...
- Schol-R-LEA
-
It does say it shouldn't be a permanent policy, though, and that it would require us to request Fandom themselves to step in.
It is something the admins should at least consider should it become necessary in the future, though I have to say it is good to hear that it has not been a significant issue in the past.
Out, damnéd Spot! Bad Doggy!
- Schol-R-LEA
-
Out, damnéd Spot! Bad Doggy!
- Sir Lee
-
They may have a valid point regarding trans terminology, but they didn't exhibit a lot of skill for working with other people.
- Schol-R-LEA
-
That having been said, as I already mentioned, I have a suspicion that had they looked more closely at the series to begin with, they would have found the premise far more offensive than the terminology - a lot of people would assume (and have in the past) that this is a fetish site, and attack the stories as 'porn' or 'objectification of women/transsexuals' (both of which accusations have been thrown at the entry on TVTropes, where several attempts to remove the series entry have been made on that basis).
Out, damnéd Spot! Bad Doggy!
- Sir Lee
-
- Nagrij
-
Sir Lee wrote: Going back to the real subject... yeah, I can concede to our Unnamed Visitor the point that "transgendered characters" is probably not the best name for the category. But "transgender" also falls short of the ideal, since it doesn't really cover many other of the characters who are not "transgender" in the usual sense. Something like "gender-variant" might work, but it's a bit too clinical for my taste and might be seen by some as disparaging. (but then again, there are people who will see anything as disparaging...)
Maybe this - Gender: malleable?
www.patreon.com/Nagrij
If you like my writing, please consider helping me out, and see the rest of the tales I spin on Patreon.
- JG
-
Transgender implies a certain amount of seeking involved.
But it's definitely better than some of the more crass terms.
Rather than trying to poke a word, if we really can't use Transgendered as an apt descriptor, put in a blurb what the situation is.
After all, Whateley has "Male, female and complicated" as the options for gender in the admin docket.
- Astrodragon
-
In RL, is there a class for 'changed into a biologically accuratel woman', or 'forcibly changed into a biologically accurate woman without any say in it' ??
I love watching their innocent little faces smiling happily as they trip gaily down the garden path, before finding the pit with the rusty spikes.
- Valentine
-
Sir Lee wrote: Going back to the real subject... yeah, I can concede to our Unnamed Visitor the point that "transgendered characters" is probably not the best name for the category. But "transgender" also falls short of the ideal, since it doesn't really cover many other of the characters who are not "transgender" in the usual sense. Something like "gender-variant" might work, but it's a bit too clinical for my taste and might be seen by some as disparaging. (but then again, there are people who will see anything as disparaging...)
Consider that there are very few "true*" TG characters. Jade, Toni, Megs, Delta Spike, Belle, CeeCee, and Shrike. There are about 35 Gen 1 year 1 TG students. So most of them are "forced" TGs, and some fighting it day by day.
* By "true," I mean characters that were TG before they were changed, and with Jade it might be questionable. I say questionable, only because she didn't realize it until she had manifested.
Don't Drick and Drive.
- Schol-R-LEA
-
The real problem, I think, is that we are trying to use a handful of words to describe a continuum in more dimensions than we have words to name, never mind can cover all the common polarities within. The fact that the majority of individuals (on the order of 95% or more) orbit tightly around one of two specific points in that continuum, and have been acculturated to believe that they are actually on their point (which no one actually is) and ignore or deny the existence of anything outside of those two points, makes it very hard to address this at all.
What does it mean to be transgender? For some it is the physical state of one sex or the other. For others it is acting in the prescribed gendered behavior patterns. Others still see it as presenting one's appearance within the bounds of expectations for a given sex and gender. Yet others might see it as simply being recognized by others as being the gender they identify themselves as. For others it might be something entirely different, such as auto[gyno|andro]philia (the desire for sexual experience as a person of a specific sex, something I have more experience with than a care to admit). For many transfolk, probably most, it is a combination of several things, though I doubt you would find two out of the hundreds of millions of gender-variant people in the world who would share quite the same specific set of personal needs.
Out, damnéd Spot! Bad Doggy!
- Sir Lee
-
- Arcanist Lupus
-
Astrodragon wrote: Part of the problem may be that the characters we are describing don't fit into the OTL characterisations.
In RL, is there a class for 'changed into a biologically accuratel woman', or 'forcibly changed into a biologically accurate woman without any say in it' ??
Changeling?
Sure, it's not in common usage. But supernatural transformations aren't in common appearance.
It doesn't seem like we have a Changeling category. In the WU it's mostly used to refer to people whose bodies were changed by an extra-normal event of some kind. But I could see using it as a catch-all category for complicated genders.
"Shared pain is lessened; shared joy, increased — thus do we refute entropy." - Spider Robinson
- Valentine
-
Arcanist Lupus wrote:
Astrodragon wrote: Part of the problem may be that the characters we are describing don't fit into the OTL characterisations.
In RL, is there a class for 'changed into a biologically accuratel woman', or 'forcibly changed into a biologically accurate woman without any say in it' ??
Changeling?
Sure, it's not in common usage. But supernatural transformations aren't in common appearance.
It doesn't seem like we have a Changeling category. In the WU it's mostly used to refer to people whose bodies were changed by an extra-normal event of some kind. But I could see using it as a catch-all category for complicated genders.
I think Arcanist Lupus is on to something. It will be a bit of work, and maybe some question asking, but I suggest two categories.
1) Changeling: Those that are changed from one sex to another by means other than surgery.
2) Transgender: Those that are, by our world standards, transgender. They want or are working on changing from one sex to a different sex. (I put it this way because I myself am TG, but have no desire to change from male to female, but male to nothing.)
Where Gracie fits in can be debated.
Don't Drick and Drive.
- Sir Lee
-
Delta Spike, though, is both transgender and a changeling. And so is Mega-Girl, for that matter.
Jade, also, is (so far) "only" transgender. While she's housed with the changelings, and she had to resort to somewhat unusual means to get a more female shape due to her regen, her body has not actually changed. Which is a reason I don't particularly like this separation.
"Changelings" also would exclude characters with can be either gender --or none-- depending on conditions, such as Jimmy T. or Chimera, since it sort of assumes a one-way trip.
- Sir Lee
-
The first thought that came to my mind regarded the possible use of one of the various LGBT*.* initialisms. Thinking of it a bit, I came to the opinion that it would not work, nor it would be an appropriate solution.
The reason comes back to the old chestnut of TG activism -- "Gender is who you are, sex is who you sleep with." Or something roughly similar, I didn't bother to Google for an exact quote.
Thing is, the LGBT acronym confuses the two things. Gay/Lesbian/Bisexual/Asexual relate to sexual preference, while Transgender/Transsexual relate to gender identity. This distinction is true to the "real world", and applies even more strongly to the WU, where involuntary biological gender changes are a thing. (By the way, while "Intersexed" is a bit of an odd duck for classification in real-world terms, in WU terms I think it would fit fairly well under the "gender issues" umbrella, right along with "bigendered" -- which in RW is sort of a different name for intersexed, but in WU terms can be used to define someone like Chimera.)
So, I think the first useful distinction in designing category classifications would be this one... to separate sexual preference from gender identity. We don't have currently a Gay/Lesbian/whatever category, and I'm not sure that we even need one, but if we do end up creating one, I think it should be restricted to sexual preference and not include gender identity. LGBA, if you will, instead of LGBT.
Going back to the gender-identity-issues category... I'm not sure that making a distinction between transgender and changelings is useful. Yes, one could define it as the former dealing with mental gender identity and the later dealing with body changes. But things are not that simple.
For one thing, in the WU the distinction is not always clear. Many changelings go through a stage where they have a new body-gender, but still mentally identify with their original gender -- but later, they seem to acclimate to their new body-gender. Were they "temporarily transgender?" Or were they originally transgender, and were in denial even after having their body changed?
So, for the gender part, I'm personally in favor of going for a more generalistic label, instead of splitting it into two or more reductionist ones.
- Valentine
-
Sir Lee wrote: The reason comes back to the old chestnut of TG activism -- "Gender is who you are, sex is who you sleep with." Or something roughly similar, I didn't bother to Google for an exact quote.
The one that I use, is "Gender is in your head, Sex is between your legs, and Sexuality is who you sleep with."
Don't Drick and Drive.